Hogwarts: This Hufflepuff Is a Menace!

Chapter 80: Then Hogwarts Can Do Without Me!

  • Next Chapter

The students surrounding the Hufflepuff table clapped until their palms stung.

Some had tears in their eyes.

Harry was one of them.

His parents had fought in that war. They had stood against Voldemort and died for it.

They had been brave.

And he had been swallowing Snape’s unfair treatment because he was frightened of losing points. Frightened of being expelled.

The thought made him burn with shame.

He wasn’t the only one.

Black’s speech had struck exactly the right note. Hogwarts was supposed to teach them courage, not how to keep their heads down.

For the students listening, admiration for those who had fought before them was becoming something more: a responsibility to carry on what they had started.

“We can’t let that courage die with them!” Black declared.

He stood on the table, his voice carrying to every corner of the hall.

“The house points system should never be a weapon that puts one professor above the rules. We need to stand together—and put an end to the idea that Snape can do whatever he likes!”

Hidden in a corner, Beck watched with tears streaming down his face.

He was reporting every detail to Grindelwald.

“Wonderful,” the elf whispered. “Just like the old master in his day… Such a way with people…”

Twenty minutes earlier, Dumbledore had finished listening to Snape’s account.

He took off his spectacles and polished them.

“Severus, I’m afraid I cannot see what Black has done wrong.”

Snape’s expression hardened.

“It may be time to reconsider how you deal with your students,” Dumbledore added.

“Even if my initial judgement was less than impartial, that does not excuse his arrogance. He openly challenged a professor.”

Dumbledore put his spectacles back on.

“Students are allowed to question their professors, Severus. A reasonable objection is not automatically insolence.”

He settled back in his chair.

“I will not be expelling Black. That is the end of the matter.”

Snape did not move.

“You may go,” Dumbledore said. “And remember that your principal concern remains Quirrell. Neither of us wishes to see his master return.”

An almost imperceptible shudder passed through Snape.

“If you refuse to expel him, then at least a detention—”

“A detention for what?”

The door opened.

Professor Sprout marched into the office.

“The boy did nothing wrong!”

“Pomona—”

“No, Severus. You’ve been doing this for years. Taking points whenever it suits you. Punishing students because you’re in a bad mood. I’ve let far too much of it pass.”

She stopped in front of him.

“But if you think I’ll stand by while you do this to Black, you are very much mistaken.”

She had promised Black that she wouldn’t fight Snape.

As far as she was concerned, that meant physically.

She had made no promises about keeping her mouth shut.

Besides, the students weren’t the only people at Hogwarts who had been quietly losing patience with him.

“Pomona,” Dumbledore said, attempting a soothing smile. “Surely we can—”

“Albus, he’s your own family. Doesn’t that count for anything?”

Her voice shook with anger.

“Black has done nothing wrong. Never mind expulsion or detention—I object to the points being taken in the first place.”

She turned a fierce look on Snape.

“If you punish him for this, then at least I’ll know where we stand. Apparently, treating every student fairly is a mistake. We should all start doing the opposite.”

Snape stared back at her, furious.

In all her years as Head of Hufflepuff, Sprout had rarely been this angry.

“Please calm down,” Dumbledore said. “I have no intention of punishing Black.”

“We all try to apply the points system fairly, Albus. Every one of us.”

Her eyes returned to Snape.

“With one exception.”

“Pomona—”

“If the rest of us treated Slytherin the way he treats our houses, do you think they’d have won the House Cup all these years?”

“We earned those victories,” Snape said coldly.

“Earned them? You have a remarkable talent for shamelessness, Severus. I’ll grant you that it gets results.”

She turned back to Dumbledore.

“I’ve just awarded Black a hundred and fifty points for having the courage to stand his ground. Hufflepuff is now in first place.”

Dumbledore looked at her.

“And if Severus intends to carry on as he has been,” she continued, “then so shall I.”

There was something particularly alarming about seeing a normally gentle person lose their temper.

By the time they did, they had generally exhausted every scrap of patience they possessed.

“Pomona, I have heard what happened,” Dumbledore said firmly. “Black will not be punished. In any way.”

The office door opened again.

McGonagall and Flitwick hurried inside.

“Albus! What is this about expelling Black?” McGonagall demanded. “We must establish what actually happened before—”

She caught sight of Sprout’s furious face and stopped.

For one dreadful moment, she thought the decision had already been made.

“Black?” said a voice from the wall. “Which Black?”

Phineas Nigellus Black had just returned to his portrait and was looking down with sudden interest.

“Not one of yours,” another former headmaster told him. “It’s the boy’s first name.”

“Oh.”

Phineas looked faintly disappointed, or perhaps merely confused.

“Everyone, please,” Dumbledore said. “I have already heard the account. Black is not being expelled.”

The newcomers visibly relaxed.

“Now, if we could consider this matter—”

“No, Professor Dumbledore,” Sprout interrupted. “We cannot consider it closed.”

Dumbledore waited.

“Severus must agree to stop taking points without proper cause. The rest of us reward good work and penalise misconduct, whatever house a student belongs to.”

Her voice sharpened.

“We don’t punish them for doing well. Why should he be allowed to?”

McGonagall and Flitwick turned towards Snape.

Their expressions suggested they were waiting for an answer too.

Dumbledore nodded.

“Severus? I think a response is called for. Your judgements have not always been impartial.”

Snape gave a soft, contemptuous snort.

“We all have our own standards. If I do not consider a student’s work worthy of points, I do not award any. Is that now forbidden?”

No one looked impressed.

“Potions requires precision,” he continued. “A small error can produce something lethal. I consider mistakes in my classroom serious. If losing points helps students remember that, I fail to see the objection.”

“And Black?” Sprout demanded. “He brewed his potion successfully. Why did you take points instead of awarding them?”

“His mediocre effort did not merit a reward.”

Snape sounded almost bored.

“And he was standing less than ten inches from his classmates. He watched them make a mistake and said nothing. I see no reason to withdraw the deduction.”

Sprout’s hand twitched towards her pocket.

“All this fuss over one first-year,” Snape added. “Do you not think you’re being a little excessive?”

McGonagall caught Sprout firmly by the arm.

She had seen the trowel.

“It was his first attempt at brewing a potion!” Sprout snapped. “You utterly—”

The door opened once more.

Quirrell stepped inside.

He glanced around the crowded office, and a bead of sweat appeared on his forehead.

“I—I heard that Black was… was to be expelled. I d-don’t think that would be…”

Dumbledore stared at him.

Even Quirrell had come.

Voldemort must have taken a considerable interest in something about the boy.

Snape gave Quirrell a look of undisguised disgust and strode towards the door.

Before he reached it, one of the portraits spoke.

“You might wish to visit the Great Hall. Things are becoming rather lively.”

The former headmaster had another portrait there.

“What sort of things?” Dumbledore asked.

“The boy. Black. He believes he’s being expelled, and he’s giving a speech.”

“A speech?”

An all too familiar figure flashed through Dumbledore’s mind.

He rose at once.

“Come.”

Whatever else he had intended to say to Snape could wait.

They heard the applause long before they reached the Great Hall.

Then Black’s voice rose above it.

Dumbledore raised a hand, stopping the others just out of sight.

He wanted to hear this.

“Professor Snape told me to pack my things. Apparently, I’m being thrown out of Hogwarts tonight…”

The professors listened.

Black’s voice carried clearly through the doors.

“No. It isn’t.

“Hogwarts is supposed to teach us more than spells and facts. It should teach us to stand up to people who abuse their power. To have the courage to resist.”

McGonagall’s expression changed.

“Think about the war. Think about the witches and wizards who left this school and chose to stand against You-Know-Who…”

As Black spoke of those who had died, her eyes grew wet.

So many people.

So many children they had taught.

They had been so young.

Faces rose in the professors’ memories: lively, stubborn, brave faces that would never grow older.

Courage, not silence.

Resistance, not simply keeping oneself safe.

The boy had put it beautifully.

“Fear and silence are not the lessons Hogwarts should leave us with. The students who came before us proved that with their lives.”

Snape’s face, meanwhile, alternated between white and red.

The little wretch was turning the entire school against him.

Dumbledore’s expression was harder to read.

A young figure speaking with absolute conviction. A crowd hanging on every word, then breaking into cheers.

For a moment, the boy on the table blurred with someone from his memories.

A brief, painful nostalgia stirred in his chest.

“Whatever house we belong to, we need to stand together.

“And together, we say no to unfairness!”

“Albus.”

McGonagall’s voice was quiet. Her eyes were still red.

“We should go in.”

Dumbledore blinked.

“Yes. Of course.”

He led the professors into the hall.

Black was still working the crowd when several Gold Chest notifications sounded in his head.

Ah.

The staff must have arrived.

Sure enough, they appeared by the high table a moment later.

“Professor Dumbledore is here,” Black announced. “Now we can tell him what we want.”

The students surged towards the staff.

“Professor!” Cedric called. “First of all, we’re asking you to withdraw Black’s expulsion!”

“And we want something done about Professor Snape’s unfair treatment!” Lee Jordan added.

Snape turned his glare on him.

Normally, that look would have been quite enough to make a student reconsider whatever they had been about to say.

Not now.

Black had spent far too long winding everyone up. Half of them looked ready to storm the dungeons and drag Snape out themselves.

His glare only made them angrier.

“Why did I get detention when a Slytherin made exactly the same mistake and only got a warning?”

“Professor Dumbledore, last year—”

“And what about—”

Black stepped down from the Hufflepuff table.

There.

The whole thing could run quite happily without him now.

He watched the professors disappear behind a crowd of students, each with something they had been waiting months—or years—to say.

Then he turned and quietly left the hall.

Best to make one’s exit while everyone else was occupied.

“Beck.”

The elf appeared with a crack, looking up at him in open adoration.

Black waved a hand.

“Pack my things. I’m being expelled.”

Beck’s ears lifted.

“Then Hogwarts can do without me.”

“Yes, young master!”

The elf hurried away to the dormitory, delighted.

Black knew perfectly well that he wasn’t going to be expelled.

But if he was putting on a performance, he might as well finish it properly.

Snape had told him he would be out of Hogwarts tonight.

Very well.

He was preparing to leave.

What was that? They weren’t expelling him after all?

They wanted him to come back?

Absolutely not.

He would go back to the orphanage.

At least there, doing something well earned him a sweet.

Here, it earned him lost points and insults.

They really insisted on having him back?

Fine.

Snape could come and apologise in person.

If you find any errors (non-standard content, ads redirect, broken links, etc..), Please let us know so we can fix it as soon as possible.

Report

Use arrow keys (or A / D) to PREV/NEXT chapter