Hogwarts: This Hufflepuff Is a Menace!

Chapter 81: That Is Bullying, Plain and Simple

  • Next Chapter

Snape was beginning to feel uneasy.

The students gathered below him looked ready to tear him apart.

He had taught this way for years. Unconsciously, he had adopted much the same approach Voldemort had used with the Death Eaters: relentless pressure, fear, and no tolerance for dissent.

Unpleasant, perhaps. Frightening, certainly.

But effective.

While the Dark Lord had been in power, no one had dared stand against him. And until Black had arrived, Snape’s methods had worked perfectly well in his own classroom.

Students feared him. No one dared disrupt his lessons.

As far as he was concerned, the results spoke for themselves.

Yet now, because of one boy, students and professors alike were turning against him.

Dumbledore looked at his pale face.

“I hope this has helped you understand where you have gone wrong, Severus.”

Snape said nothing.

“I am not asking you to greet every student with a smile. But I do expect you to treat them fairly.”

Dumbledore’s voice remained quiet.

“Students and professors are people, just as you are. They have feelings. You cannot continually disregard the fact that they have tempers, too.”

For a moment, Snape stood perfectly still.

Then he turned and left without a word.

Dumbledore watched him go before raising a hand to quieten the students.

“I have heard your concerns. And I assure you, Professor Snape will have something to reflect upon after today.”

The hall settled.

“For the next two months, I will personally review every points deduction he makes. Any deduction I find unjustified will be reversed. Those that are justified will stand.”

He looked over the gathered students.

“At the end of those two months, we shall see whether there has been an improvement.”

That seemed reasonable enough.

No one was demanding that Snape become pleasant. They wanted him to be fair.

He was hardly the only strict professor at Hogwarts. McGonagall could be terrifying, but she applied the same standards to everyone.

They respected her for it.

“What about Black, Professor?” Cedric asked. “What’s going to happen to him?”

Dumbledore smiled.

“He has done nothing wrong. Naturally, he will not be punished.”

A ripple passed through the crowd.

“And I should mention that Professor Sprout has awarded him a hundred and fifty points for having the courage to stand his ground. A decision with which I fully agree.”

The cheering shook the Great Hall.

The Hufflepuffs were beside themselves.

A hundred and fifty points!

Even if Snape had still been allowed to take points whenever he pleased, it would have taken him quite a few lessons to get through that lot.

“Black!”

Students turned, searching the crowd.

They had a very clear idea of what they wanted to do: hoist him into the air and throw him up until he regretted becoming their hero.

But there was no sign of him.

“Black?” Dumbledore called.

Nothing.

The headmaster’s smile faded.

The portrait had said the boy believed he was being expelled.

Had he simply left?

If Black truly wanted to disappear, finding him would be difficult. He had a house-elf, and house-elf Apparition could take him almost anywhere.

A thoroughly unwelcome possibility occurred to Dumbledore.

“Er… Professor?” a student said. “I think I heard him ask his house-elf to pack his things. Then he went outside.”

Dumbledore strode out of the hall.

McGonagall and the others remained behind. Someone needed to settle the students before their victory celebrations brought the roof down.

Black had no intention of actually leaving.

He had sent Beck to collect his luggage, then found several reasons to linger by the entrance.

Only when he spotted Dumbledore approaching did he take the elf’s hand.

“Wait! Black!”

Black reluctantly let go.

“I’m sorry, Professor. I’ve been expelled. I couldn’t face you, so I thought it would be better if I left on my own.”

He lowered his eyes.

“And I don’t think I could face going back to Godric’s Hollow, either. I’ll return to the orphanage.”

Dumbledore sighed.

“Do you have so little faith in me?”

Black looked up.

“How could you think I would expel you? You have done nothing wrong. Even if everything Professor Snape accused you of were true, it would hardly warrant expulsion.”

“I don’t see how I can stay.”

Black sounded weary.

“Snape won’t let this go. Perhaps he won’t do anything openly, but how am I supposed to know he won’t find some other way to get back at me?”

He paused.

“He’s a Potions master.”

“Black—”

“No. I’d rather leave than stake my life on Professor Snape suddenly developing a conscience.”

He reached for Beck again.

“Come on. Let’s go.”

“The old master has other houses!” Beck said eagerly. “We could stay in one of those!”

“Could we?”

“Oh, yes!”

Dumbledore felt his stomach drop.

A house belonging to Grindelwald?

If the boy went there, Nurmengard would be empty by morning.

“Black, I promised Mrs Marian that I would look after you. I cannot simply let you leave like this.”

He stepped closer.

“And Hogwarts has not expelled you. I give you my word that Professor Snape will not use his lessons to retaliate against you.”

Black hesitated.

“Really?”

Encouraged, Dumbledore nodded.

“Yes. I believe today will have helped him recognise his mistakes.”

“Do you?”

Dumbledore stopped.

“Never mind whether I believe that,” Black said. “Do you honestly believe it?”

The headmaster considered the question.

Severus might recognise that he had been wrong.

Admitting it was another matter entirely.

Still, with Dumbledore watching, he surely wouldn’t attempt anything underhanded against the boy.

“If he apologises,” Black said, “I’ll believe he understands what he did wrong.”

Dumbledore shook his head.

“He is your professor. Asking him to apologise to you…”

He searched for the right words.

“Even if he accepts that he was mistaken, his pride would make that difficult.”

Black gave a short, humourless laugh.

“So his dignity matters because he’s a professor. What about his students?”

Dumbledore said nothing.

“The ones he calls idiots and useless lumps every day. Don’t they have any dignity?”

Black’s expression hardened.

“He may be brilliant at Potions. That doesn’t mean he has the character to be a good teacher.”

“He is still a professor—”

“You apologised to me.”

Dumbledore fell silent.

“When you thought I’d upset Professor Sprout, and then realised you’d misunderstood, you apologised.”

Black met his eyes.

“You’re the headmaster. If you can admit you’re wrong, why can’t he? If he had a tenth of your decency, there wouldn’t be so many people who resented him.”

Dumbledore had been ready to reprimand him that morning, believing Sprout’s tears were the result of some dreadful behaviour on Black’s part.

Instead, she had been moved by what he had done for Hufflepuff.

Once Dumbledore realised his mistake, he had apologised privately.

Black had been touched by that.

One of the most important wizards in the world had acknowledged that he had wronged an eleven-year-old boy.

That took a certain strength of character.

“You give me rather too much credit,” Dumbledore said gently. “But people are different. I see no difficulty in offering an apology. Severus, on the other hand…”

He trailed off.

Getting Snape to admit a mistake aloud would be hard enough.

An apology might require a miracle.

“An apology to me isn’t even the important part,” Black said. “I’m not particularly bothered about that.”

Dumbledore waited.

“I want him to apologise to the other students. The ones he’s humiliated.”

His voice had become quieter.

“Perhaps you don’t know how bad it’s been. Or perhaps you’ve heard and thought it wasn’t serious. But some of the older students have told me what happened to them.”

Dumbledore’s expression grew still.

“What they’re describing isn’t ordinary criticism from a teacher.”

Black looked directly at him.

“It’s bullying. Plain and simple.”

He wasn’t saying it merely for effect.

In the original story, Neville’s greatest fear had been Snape.

Not a monster. Not a Dark wizard lurking in the shadows.

His Potions professor.

Every lesson brought the prospect of being singled out, losing points, and enduring another stream of insults. Snape had even threatened to test Neville’s badly brewed potion on Trevor.

A pet the boy loved.

Black could see no meaningful distinction between that and bullying.

Except that this was worse in one respect: the bully was the teacher.

Anything he did could be defended as being for the student’s own good.

Who were they supposed to complain to?

There had been plenty of poor Potions students over the years. Black doubted Neville was the only one Snape had ever treated that way.

Dumbledore’s face was grave now.

He had not paid enough attention to this.

He had considered Severus strict, certainly. But strictness was not necessarily a fault in a teacher. Minerva was strict.

If what Black described was happening, however, then the problem went well beyond high standards.

And, knowing Severus, he could not dismiss the possibility.

“Go back to your dormitory, Black.”

His tone had changed.

“Tomorrow is Saturday. Have a proper rest. I will find out exactly what has been happening.”

He paused.

“And if matters are as serious as you say, I will act.”

Black nodded.

He hadn’t truly intended to leave. This was a perfectly good place to stop pushing.

Actually going off to join Grindelwald would be rather premature.

Nurmengard might find itself accommodating a second, considerably smaller resident.

As Black returned to the castle, Dumbledore hurried away.

Whether he was going to question Snape or speak to the students, Black couldn’t tell.

He had other things to worry about.

Chiefly, the crowd waiting for him in the Great Hall.

The moment they got hold of him, his feet left the floor.

“Black! Our king!”

Fred and George led the shouting as the students threw him into the air.

“We won!”

At Nurmengard, Grindelwald was shaking.

With anger.

“Dumbledore… What sort of people are you employing?”

He stared at the reports.

“Yes, I did plenty of things you called wicked. But I was never this petty.”

His lip curled.

“Taking points for that? Deliberately tormenting the boy, then threatening expulsion when he loses the argument?”

He gave a sharp, incredulous laugh.

“Your staff make my old followers look positively civilised.”

Then he read a little further.

“Oh. A former Death Eater. That explains it.”

Grindelwald leaned back.

“A former Death Eater teaching children. You’re not quite as righteous as you like to pretend, are you, Albus?”

His mood improved considerably when he reached Beck’s account of the speech.

“Good. Very good.”

He read on, smiling.

“The delivery could use a little work. But that instinct for finding exactly what will move an audience…”

His smile widened.

“That is mine.”

The boy had understood, without anyone needing to teach him, that a weaker individual could gather others and challenge someone far stronger.

“I told you he took after me, Dumbledore.”

Grindelwald chuckled.

“At this rate, he’ll soon discover just how satisfying it is to know what people want—and how to make them follow you.”

That evening, the Hufflepuff common room hosted an enormous celebration.

Even Professor Sprout joined in the singing and dancing.

For the students, it was about more than a hundred and fifty points.

Thanks to Black, they finally had an answer for anyone who called Hufflepuff the house for idiots.

Had those people never heard of Black Grin?

The first-year who had been threatened with expulsion, rallied the school, and challenged Snape’s right to do as he pleased?

The boy whom three Heads of House had rushed to defend?

If that was their idea of an idiot, what extraordinary feats had they managed themselves?

With no lessons the following morning, the celebrations went on late.

Black, as the guest of honour, was obliged to remain until the end.

By the time he finally climbed into bed, his head felt decidedly woolly.

Wasn’t butterbeer supposed to be harmless?

He lay still for a while, waiting for the room to settle.

Then, at last, he spoke silently.

“System. Open my chest storage.”

Time for the truly important part.

“I want to combine my chests.”

If you liked the chapter

If you find any errors (non-standard content, ads redirect, broken links, etc..), Please let us know so we can fix it as soon as possible.

Report

Use arrow keys (or A / D) to PREV/NEXT chapter