Hogwarts: This Hufflepuff Is a Menace!
Chapter 79: Together, We Say No
“Thank you for believing me, Professor Sprout. And for standing up for me.”
Black meant it.
So far, she had only heard his account. She hadn’t even checked it with anyone else, yet she had already decided to trust him—and to defend him with everything she had.
It was rather touching.
“But I don’t want you and Professor Snape to fall out over this,” he added. “That would put Professor Dumbledore in a very difficult position.”
Sprout’s expression softened.
Even now, the boy was thinking of Dumbledore. He was willing to forgo her help rather than cause trouble for him.
What a thoughtful child.
And Severus wanted to expel him.
The man was asking for it.
“All right. I’ll support you from behind the scenes,” she said. “If nothing comes of this, I’m willing to let the matter rest for now. But if anyone actually tries to expel you—or punish you—then I make no promises.”
She moved towards the door.
“Go and have something to eat. I need a word with Professor Dumbledore.”
Black looked at her.
“Only to find out what he intends to do,” she assured him. “I won’t start a fight with Severus.”
She opened the door to find Cedric and Marcus standing outside.
“Black! There you are!”
“Professor Sprout, they can’t expel him!” Marcus blurted out.
Quite apart from the fact that Black hadn’t deserved any of this, Hufflepuff had finally found a truly exceptional Quidditch player.
And Snape wanted to throw him out before they’d even played a match?
“Don’t worry, boys. Go and get your dinner. I’m on my way to see the headmaster.”
Sprout’s voice was firm.
“No one is expelling Black. And I intend to have an explanation for those points Severus took, too.”
She stepped out with them.
Black noticed the little trowel disappearing into her pocket.
“Professor…”
“Don’t worry, dear. I promised, didn’t I? I’ll do my best not to quarrel with Severus.”
There seemed to be a certain amount of teeth-gritting involved in that promise.
They parted in the corridor, and Cedric and Marcus accompanied Black towards the Great Hall.
“Everyone’s talking about what happened,” Cedric said anxiously. “You and Snape.”
Black nodded.
He had noticed.
The notifications hadn’t stopped ringing in his head. In what felt like no time at all, the chests in his system storage had filled three whole pages.
Most were Bronze, with the occasional Silver. A few Gold Chests had appeared when the news first broke, though those were much rarer now.
“You were too rash,” Cedric continued. “Everyone knows what Snape’s like. Usually, you just put up with it until the lesson’s over. But answering him back like that… What if he really does get you expelled?”
“I don’t regret it.”
Black’s reply was perfectly calm.
“I followed his instructions. I didn’t make a single mistake with my potion. What right did he have to invent a reason to take points?”
“I know, but—”
“I was going to let it go. I even apologised. And he decided that counted as insolence.”
His mouth tightened.
“I tried being reasonable. He took that as an invitation to be worse. If I hadn’t said something, I wouldn’t have slept tonight.”
“I’m with you,” Marcus said. “And you needn’t worry. Cedric and I have already written a petition asking them to reconsider. We’ll get every Hufflepuff to sign it.”
“Thank you. Both of you.”
Black paused.
“But that’s part of the problem, isn’t it?”
They looked at him.
“I didn’t do anything wrong. Why should you have to beg anyone to forgive me?”
Cedric exchanged a glance with Marcus.
“What do you want to do?”
Black stopped walking.
“Outside Slytherin, students in every year are afraid to stand up to Snape. First-years, seventh-years—it makes no difference. Everyone resents it, but no one dares say anything.”
He looked from one to the other.
“Hogwarts has been putting up with him for far too long.”
“You’re telling me,” Marcus muttered. “This is my seventh year. Seven years of that face. Even when I was a first-year, the older students warned us about him.”
He sighed.
“He’s always been like this. What are we supposed to do?”
Black clapped a hand on his broad shoulder.
“Marcus. Does something become right just because it’s always been done?”
The captain fell silent.
“He gets away with it because everyone’s afraid to be the first to complain,” Black went on. “Well, he’s already told me I’ll be out of Hogwarts tonight. What else have I got to be afraid of?”
His gaze sharpened.
“Even if he means it, I’m still a Hogwarts student until then. I can still speak up for the rest of us.”
Cedric was listening intently now.
“Everyone who’s been bullied or treated unfairly needs to stand together. Whatever year they’re in. Whatever house they belong to. None of us should have to accept this.”
Cedric and Marcus looked at each other again.
Black clearly intended to fight this all the way.
And, despite themselves, they were beginning to feel rather eager to join him.
“We’ll support you,” Cedric said.
“Absolutely,” Marcus added.
“Good.” Black turned towards the Great Hall. “It’s dinner time. That’s where everyone will be.”
With the weekend ahead, the Great Hall was particularly crowded. Friday lessons were over, and plenty of students had settled down to enjoy their dinner without any pressing reason to leave.
The noise reached the three boys before they reached the doors.
Then Black walked in.
Within seconds, the conversations died away.
Faces turned towards him along all four tables.
“Hero!”
Someone shouted it from the crowd.
Applause followed.
It spread through the hall until even a few students at the Slytherin table were clapping.
Not every Slytherin enjoyed Draco Malfoy’s treatment, after all.
Black glanced towards the staff table.
To his surprise, it was empty.
Students were already getting up and gathering around him.
“That was incredibly reckless,” Hermione told him, hurrying over. “But I spoke to Professor McGonagall. She’s gone to see Professor Dumbledore.”
“You haven’t done anything to deserve expulsion,” Cassandra said firmly. “They won’t throw you out.”
“Professor Flitwick’s gone to see the headmaster as well,” Penelope added.
That explained the empty chairs.
Apart from Snape, Black had a rather good reputation among the staff. Apparently, news of his impending expulsion had sent them all towards Dumbledore’s office.
The most extraordinary part was that Quirrell had gone too.
Really, Tom? That worried about losing me?
And I’m supposed to believe you aren’t after my body.
All around him, students were offering their approval.
“Well done, Black!”
“You said what the rest of us have wanted to say for years!”
“I’ve always hated the way he treats us. He just never listens.”
“I argued with him once. He gave me a fortnight’s detention!”
The last speaker sounded perilously close to tears.
Not everyone was pleased, however.
Most of the Slytherin table remained quiet. Plenty of them knew perfectly well that their Head of House had been in the wrong.
A few were less inclined to admit it.
“Since when does being rude to a professor make you a hero?” someone called.
“Professor Snape’s perfectly fair,” another voice declared. “He’s just as strict with us!”
“He doesn’t single anyone out!”
Angry faces turned towards the Slytherin table.
That was a remarkable claim to make in a room full of witnesses.
Yes, Snape was strict with his own students. He simply tended to stop short of taking points from them.
A mistake that cost Gryffindor five points might earn a Slytherin a sharp word or two.
Apparently, that was fairness.
Black stepped forward.
“Have any of you watched him teach another house?”
His voice carried across the hall.
“And even if you haven’t, you’ve shared his lessons with students from other houses. Haven’t you noticed what happens?”
No one answered.
“If someone gets a question wrong, most professors explain the answer. They don’t take points for it. Snape does. Five points for one wrong answer.”
He held up a hand.
“Five. Elsewhere, answering correctly might earn you one or two points. In Potions, a single mistake can wipe out all of it.”
A murmur of agreement ran through the crowd.
“But let’s accept that for a moment. Let’s say he thinks we should have prepared better. Why, then, don’t we get points when we answer correctly?”
Black looked directly towards the students who had spoken.
“Why did a perfectly brewed potion earn nothing?”
“In his lessons, doing everything perfectly only means he might not take points away. If that’s your idea of fairness, it’s an insult to every other professor in this school.”
The applause returned at once.
“Exactly!”
“I’ve never seen him take points from your lot!”
“I’m in fifth year. I’ve never earned a single point in his classroom!”
“McGonagall’s fair! She takes points from her own house!”
“Plenty of them!”
“Can you say the same about Snape?”
Black let the voices rise around him.
Then he stepped onto a bench and climbed onto the Hufflepuff table.
“Everyone!”
Faces lifted towards him.
“Professor Snape told me to pack my things. Apparently, I’m being thrown out of Hogwarts tonight.”
The hall began to quieten.
“But whatever happens, I’m still a student here right now.”
He swept his gaze across the crowd.
“For years, people have been angry about the way he treats us, but no one has wanted to speak up. And why would they? The first person to object becomes his next target.”
A few students nodded grimly.
“Well, he’s already decided to expel me. He’s run out of things to threaten me with.”
Black straightened.
“So I’ll be the first.”
The applause was louder this time.
He raised a hand and waited for it to subside.
“The house points system is supposed to encourage us to do well. When we achieve something, we earn points. When we break the rules, we lose them. There’s nothing unfair about that.”
He paused.
“But Professor Snape has turned it into a way of settling personal grudges.”
The students stood packed around the table, listening.
“If he dislikes you, he can take points whenever he pleases. And however well you do, if you’re not a Slytherin, you can forget about earning any from him.”
Black’s voice hardened.
“Object, and you’re accused of insolence. More points gone. Detention, if he feels like it. How is that fair?”
It was not a question that invited an answer.
“The other professors have let it pass because he’s their colleague. But every time they let it pass, he’s been encouraged to keep doing it.”
Black looked towards the empty staff table, then back at the students.
“They may be willing to stay silent. We shouldn’t be.”
The hall was still now.
“We’re supposed to be learning here. If we learn to keep quiet whenever something is wrong because we’re frightened of the consequences, what happens when we leave?”
His eyes moved over the older students.
“Do we carry on doing it? Keep our heads down? Accept whatever happens to us because speaking up might be inconvenient?”
He let the questions hang.
“Is that what Hogwarts is supposed to teach us?”
“No,” someone said.
“No,” Black agreed. “It isn’t.”
His voice rose.
“Hogwarts is supposed to teach us more than spells and facts. It should teach us to stand up to people who abuse their power. To have the courage to resist.”
Students from all four houses were watching him now.
“Think about the war. Think about the witches and wizards who left this school and chose to stand against You-Know-Who.”
The name—or rather, the absence of it—sent a faint stir through the hall.
“They knew how dangerous he was. They fought anyway. Some of them died so that we could live in peace.”
Black’s expression had grown solemn.
“If Hogwarts had only taught them to look after themselves and avoid trouble, would they have done that? Would they have left school and gone straight into a war?”
He shook his head.
“They had the courage to stand up to You-Know-Who. And we can’t find the courage to stand up to one unfair professor?”
No one spoke.
“We owe ourselves better than that.”
Black stood above the sea of upturned faces.
“Fear and silence are not the lessons Hogwarts should leave us with. The students who came before us proved that with their lives.”
He drew a breath.
“Whatever house we belong to, we need to stand together.”
His voice rang through the Great Hall.
“And together, we say no to unfairness!”
If you find any errors (non-standard content, ads redirect, broken links, etc..), Please let us know so we can fix it as soon as possible.
ReportUse arrow keys (or A / D) to PREV/NEXT chapter
Loading comments…