Hogwarts: This Hufflepuff Is a Menace!
Chapter 78: I Question Whether You’re Fit to Be a Professor
That counted as talking back?
Watching Black lose another five points for no good reason, Wayne nearly tipped his lurid green potion over Snape’s greasy head.
Roger caught his arm.
The older pupils had warned them before their first Potions lesson.
Snape rarely troubled himself with fairness when taking points. They were to be careful.
So they had expected some unreasonable behaviour.
They hadn’t expected quite this much.
Originally, Snape had only intended to make Black uncomfortable.
If the boy had failed to answer his questions, as Potter had that morning, Snape could have made a few cutting remarks and moved on.
Black, however, had refused to cooperate.
He knew the answers, so he gave them.
He knew how to brew the potion, so he brewed it.
Snape hadn’t found a single legitimate reason to take points.
Unfortunately, he now felt that his authority had suffered.
Which meant he was determined to take some anyway.
Around them, the Hufflepuffs seethed in silence.
Even the Ravenclaws thought he had gone too far.
The points belonged to the whole House.
In the past, Hufflepuff might have let that pass. Now, with everyone making an effort, each point represented somebody’s hard work.
They mattered.
Blaming Black for another pair’s failed potion was absurd.
He and Hannah had finished first. With any other professor, they would probably have earned points.
Snape had taken them instead.
Then Black had accepted the blame.
His apology had carried an implication, certainly, but it had still been an apology.
Snape had called it defiance and taken more points.
Every eye settled on Black.
What could he do?
The older pupils had endured it for years. He would have to swallow his anger as well.
Snape was a professor.
That was how these things worked.
Snape evidently agreed.
He turned towards the front of the classroom.
Others had protested before. Their protests had merely cost them more points, and sometimes earned them detention.
Resistance achieved nothing.
‘One moment, Professor Snape.’
Black was still smiling.
He looked almost untouched by what had happened.
Snape stopped and turned, looking down at the eleven-year-old.
‘What is it now, Grin?’
His voice dripped contempt.
‘Have you decided to beg for points? For Black Grin, the pupil in whom Dumbledore takes such an interest?’
He put particular emphasis on Black’s name.
It was as though some of his resentment towards another Black had found a convenient new target.
‘No, Professor. I have a question.’
‘You wish to question me?’
Snape’s mouth curved.
This might be entertaining.
‘Further insolence. Hufflepuff loses—’
‘You can deduct the points for this conversation afterwards. First, please answer my question.’
Black’s smile faded.
‘What, exactly, did I say before that counted as talking back?’
Snape stared at him.
‘Or do you simply dislike me and intend to take points regardless?’
‘You overestimate your importance, Mr Grin. You scarcely warrant such attention.’
‘Then explain why you deducted the points. I followed your instructions throughout the lesson and brewed the potion correctly.’
Black’s voice remained level.
‘I don’t believe I earned a penalty.’
‘I have already explained. You failed to remind Hopkins and Malone about the dried nettles.’
‘So I lost points because I didn’t perform your teaching duties for you?’
The room went very still.
‘Or have I misunderstood? Is teaching us to brew potions not your job?’
Black tilted his head.
‘Is taking points your job instead?’
Silence.
The pupils knew this was a terrible idea.
That didn’t stop them enjoying it.
A dangerous glint appeared in Snape’s eyes.
‘Grin. For once again challenging a professor, Hufflepuff loses—’
‘Then I was right.’
Black cut across him again.
‘Taking points is your job. In that case, why am I calling you Professor?’
Nobody moved.
‘If you do nothing but penalise pupils while expecting other pupils to teach them, what qualifies you for the title?’
Snape’s face tightened.
‘Perhaps I should ask Professor Dumbledore for a position. I think I could do better. At least I could invent more convincing reasons.’
Black paused.
‘Malfoy entered the classroom right foot first. Fifty points from Slytherin.’
He looked up at Snape.
‘What do you think? Is that better than yours?’
The only sound in the dungeon was Snape’s breathing.
Every pupil stared at Black with the same thought.
He had lost his mind.
He could actually be expelled for this.
‘You are challenging a professor’s authority,’ Snape said coldly. ‘I assure you, you will be expelled from Hogwarts.’
‘No, Snape. I’m questioning whether you’re fit to hold that authority.’
Black met his eyes.
‘Whether you possess the character expected of a professor.’
Snape went rigid.
‘You want to expel me for answering you back? If this school can tolerate a professor like you, why can’t it tolerate me?’
The colour drained from Snape’s face.
He couldn’t tell whether the boy had intended it.
But those words struck deep.
A professor like you.
Years ago, after realising the terrible mistake he had made and the danger he had brought upon Lily, he had confessed to Dumbledore.
He had begged for her child to be protected.
He had agreed to serve as Dumbledore’s spy.
After Voldemort disappeared, Dumbledore had vouched for him. His testimony had spared Snape punishment by the Ministry.
Then he had given him a post at Hogwarts.
Dumbledore had tolerated him.
A man who had helped bring about Lily’s death.
A man who would never forgive himself.
Black’s words tore at that old wound.
If Hogwarts could tolerate what Snape had done, what was a child’s insolence by comparison?
The meaning Snape found in the accusation pushed him almost beyond reason.
‘One hundred points from Hufflepuff.’
His voice shook with anger.
‘Pack your belongings. You will be leaving Hogwarts tonight.’
He turned on the room.
‘Out. All of you. Get out!’
Chairs scraped.
Pupils hurried to collect their things and flee.
Snape’s expression was frightening enough that nobody wanted to remain within reach of his temper.
Black left last.
He could feel Snape glaring at his back until he passed through the dungeon door.
He gave a cold little smile.
Expel him?
Hardly.
Even if Black had been in the wrong, Dumbledore would probably have given him detention.
And Black considered himself firmly in the right.
Snape’s arbitrary deductions had started the whole thing.
He didn’t believe Dumbledore would ignore that.
But if he did support expulsion…
Very well.
Black could go over to the other side.
He would make quite sure Dumbledore couldn’t find him.
Then, a few years later, he could start a revolution.
See how the headmaster liked that.
His first Potions lesson had certainly ended with more excitement than expected.
Two Gold Chests and a Diamond from Snape.
A pile of other rewards from the pupils.
An excellent haul.
As for the points, provided he remained at school, he had plenty of ways to earn them back.
Black didn’t head for Dumbledore’s office.
He went straight to Professor Sprout.
She had always treated him well.
He owed her an explanation for costing Hufflepuff a hundred points.
‘I demand that Black Grin be expelled.’
Snape stood before Dumbledore’s desk, furious.
The headmaster’s brow creased.
‘What has happened now?’
He felt suddenly tired.
Black was well liked by his teachers. He ought to have been a reassuringly good child.
Yet somehow, trouble kept finding him.
‘He openly challenged my authority. He was arrogant, insolent and contemptuous throughout the lesson.’
Snape’s expression hardened.
‘Leave that unchecked, and you may find yourself with another Dark Lord.’
Something sharpened in Dumbledore’s eyes.
That last accusation concerned him.
He needed the facts.
Folding his hands, he sat upright.
‘Tell me exactly what happened.’
By then, the story was spreading through Hogwarts.
Black Grin had confronted Snape in class.
Now he was going to be expelled.
Pupils from every year and every House sought out those who had witnessed it.
Snape had spent years making students miserable.
A first-year had finally answered him back—and apparently reduced him to incoherent fury.
The witnesses were more than willing to describe the lesson.
Before long, the whole school had heard the exchange.
‘What a hero.’
‘I wish I’d been there.’
‘Someone finally said it to him.’
‘Still, it was reckless. They say he’s being expelled.’
‘Dumbledore won’t expel him.’
‘He did insult a professor.’
The Gryffindors were particularly delighted.
They suffered most under Snape.
When Harry heard the story, he nearly dropped his glasses.
He was astonished.
He was also struggling not to grin.
Hermione and Cassandra had only just left the Room of Requirement when the news reached them.
Both stared in disbelief.
He had been perfectly fine at lunchtime.
How had one lesson turned into expulsion?
Hermione hurried towards McGonagall’s office.
Cassandra stayed calmer and went to find out precisely what had happened.
Fred and George began searching for Black.
They also announced that, if he survived this without being expelled, they would happily take orders from him.
Some pupils were entertained.
Others were inspired.
The Hufflepuffs were worried.
Led by Cedric, they began preparing a petition.
They couldn’t allow Black to be expelled over this.
If he had simply refused to behave, that would have been one thing.
But Snape had plainly provoked him.
Whatever Black had done wrong, expulsion was far too severe.
Cedric and Marcus searched for him without success.
Eventually, they decided to find Professor Sprout.
‘I’m going to have a word with Severus.’
Sprout’s usual kindly smile had vanished.
After hearing Black’s account, she seized a nearby trowel and looked ready to march down to the dungeons.
She had endured Snape’s favouritism for years.
She had watched him lavish attention on Slytherin and make life difficult for Gryffindor.
But now he was taking Hufflepuff’s points on invented grounds.
And treating one of her favourite pupils like that.
Then, when the boy challenged him and he couldn’t produce an answer, he threatened expulsion?
Snape wasn’t the only Head of House in this school.
Did he think being patient meant she would tolerate anything?
‘Professor, please.’
Black stepped in her way.
‘It’s all right. I’m not going to be expelled.’
He had never seen her so angry.
By all appearances, she hadn’t been this angry in years.
And she was angry on his behalf.
He was genuinely touched.
‘I won’t allow you to be expelled,’ Sprout said firmly. ‘There was nothing wrong with the point you made.’
She gripped the trowel.
‘I shall ask Professor Dumbledore whether all of us are permitted to deduct points like that. If we are, I see no reason to remain restrained.’
Then she looked directly at Black.
‘You stood up to an abuse of authority and held to what you believed was right. That is something every Hufflepuff should learn from.’
Her voice became decisive.
‘One hundred and fifty points to Hufflepuff.’
Arbitrary points?
If that was how Severus wanted to proceed, he wasn’t the only one who could do it.
If you find any errors (non-standard content, ads redirect, broken links, etc..), Please let us know so we can fix it as soon as possible.
ReportUse arrow keys (or A / D) to PREV/NEXT chapter
Loading comments…