Chapter 157: Nothing Is Given

Undefined Conviction

Chapter 157: Nothing Is Given

Somebody had filled the hole in Ivor's kitchen wall with filler and not painted it, and it sat there the whole time like a scar nobody was allowed to mention.

Nine people. Four chairs. Ivor at the table with his hands flat, the way he always sat, and Reeve opposite him with a plaster over one eyebrow and a question he had been carrying since four o'clock on a Tuesday morning.

"Ask it," Ivor said.

"You wrote on my file."

"Yes."

"When I was sixteen. Hold. Do not." Reeve's voice did not shake, which Mia noticed from the doorway. "You'd never met me. You didn't meet any of us until the lamp. And you wrote on my file two years before you'd ever heard my name."

"I'd heard your name," Ivor said. "I just hadn't met you."

He told it plainly, the way he told everything.

"In the spring of 2024 a D-Rank boy in an assessment room in the east annex was shown a paint chart and asked to identify the colour of the walls. The walls had been repainted that morning. He named the old colour." Ivor turned his cup a quarter-turn. "The assessor wrote mild recall anomaly and moved on. I read the report four days later in a pile of a thousand others and I stopped."

"Why?"

"Because I've been reading those reports since before the Ministry existed, and in four hundred years I had seen that exact note ten times before." He looked up. "All ten were reclassified within two years. I couldn't stop any of them. I didn't know where they'd be sent until afterwards."

"And me?"

"You I caught early," Ivor said. "So I wrote two words in a margin, in a hand that every clerk in that building had been trained to leave alone for forty years, and I hoped."

Dana asked the question nobody else would.

"Why does it matter? Out of every Conviction in the country, why does that one get ten people filed down to find the eleventh?"

Ivor did not answer immediately.

He looked at the unpainted filler on the wall for a while.

"Because everything they do can be undone by it," he said.

"Everything the organisation does — the smoothing, the passes, the rooms, the reclassifications — it's all the same act, done different ways." Ivor's voice was very even. "They make a person forget something. Kindly or cruelly, fast or slow, it's always that. Forgetting."

"And Refusal to Fade—"

"Refusal to Fade is a belief that nothing should be allowed to disappear." He looked at Reeve. "Held firmly enough, it doesn't just protect the person holding it. It spreads. You held that girl's hand in a café and gave her back two months, and you felt what it cost you, and I'd imagine a man at the next table rang somebody he hadn't spoken to in years."

Mia made a small sound.

"How did you—"

"Because it happened in 1911," Ivor said, "and in 1862, and I was there both times, and both times the organisation that existed then spent everything it had to find the person responsible, and both times it succeeded."

Unlawfully taken from NovelPhoenix, this story should be reported if seen on Amazon.

Nobody moved.

"So that's why," Reeve said. His voice had gone very small. "They're not looking for me because I'm dangerous. They're looking for me because I can fix it."

"Yes."

"Everything they've ever done."

"Given enough time, and enough of you, and people who want it back." Ivor turned the cup again. "Yes. Everything."

Cole had not spoken since they sat down.

He was standing by the window with his arms folded, and every person in that kitchen had been aware of him the whole time in the way you're aware of weather.

"They'll come for him," he said.

"Yes," Ivor said. "Now that they know where he is. Harriet Slade's team was the gentle version and it failed and they'll have reported why. The next ones won't be gentle."

"How many?"

"I don't know. As many as it takes. Twice in two centuries it took everything they had." Ivor looked at him directly. "I want to be accurate with you. Whatever comes next will be larger than a kitchen."

Cole unfolded his arms.

"Then they'll have to come through me," he said.

He didn't raise his voice. He didn't need to. Reeve would say afterward that it was the first time he'd ever heard Cole say something that sounded less like a promise and more like a fact — the way you'd tell somebody the time.

Ivor looked at him for a long moment.

"That," he said quietly, "is what I was hoping somebody would say in 1862."

Elena said it at about four o'clock.

She had been sitting on the counter by the kettle for two hours and had said nothing, and when she spoke everybody turned round.

"Do me."

"Elena—" Dana was on her feet.

"I've had four years of a thing I can't get into." Elena's hands were in her lap. "Somebody read me terms. I told you that. I can feel the shape of it and I can't get in, and there's a boy in this kitchen who just walked into a café and let a stranger back into her own head."

"You don't know what's in there."

"No. That's the point." She looked at her sister. "Dana, you've spent four years finding out everything about what happened to me. Every file, every form, every ledger. You know more about my four years than I do."

Dana did not answer.

"I'd like to catch up," Elena said.

Reeve looked at Cole.

And Cole — who would have made this decision in about four seconds a year ago, who had built an entire life around deciding what people could handle — said:

"It's not mine."

"Cole—"

"It's hers. And it's yours." He stepped back from the window. "I'm not in this one."

Vesper was sitting on the floor by the fridge with her knees up, where she'd been for most of the afternoon.

She did not say anything. But Mia, who was next to her, saw her look up at Cole for a long moment — the first time she'd looked straight at him since breakfast four days ago — and saw something in her face set, quietly and deliberately.

Not forgiveness. Mia was sure of that.

Something closer to a note being taken.

Dana had not sat back down.

"If it goes wrong—"

"Then it goes wrong in a kitchen with nine people who love me in it," Elena said, "which is a great deal better than the last time something was done to my head."

Dana stood there for a moment longer.

Then she sat down next to her sister, and took her other hand, which she had not done since the swimming pool, and said nothing at all.

Reeve did not start straight away.

He sat across from Elena with both hands flat on the table and looked at them for a while, and nobody hurried him.

"I don't know what I'm doing," he said.

"I know."

"No — I mean I really don't. With Lottie I didn't decide anything, I just held on, and it happened." He swallowed. "If I get it wrong, I don't know what wrong looks like. I don't know if I can make it worse."

"Reeve," Elena said. "I spent four years in a room with people who knew exactly what they were doing."

She put her hand out, palm up, on the table between them.

"I'd rather have you."

It took less than a minute this time.

Reeve took Elena's hand across the kitchen table and closed his eyes, and the room did the thing the café had done — came gently, completely into focus, as though it had been slightly blurred for years and nobody had noticed.

Elena's breath caught.

She did not cry. She did not make a sound. She sat very still with her eyes open and her hand in Reeve's, and her lips moved, silently, the way people's lips move when they're reading something to themselves.

Then she said, out loud, in a voice that was not quite hers — slower, flatter, the voice of somebody reciting:

"Nothing is given."

Across the table, Ivor's cup hit the floor.

It did not break. It rolled under the table and nobody moved to get it, because every person in that kitchen was looking at a four-hundred-year-old man who had never once in their presence been surprised by anything.

His face had gone the colour of the unpainted filler.

"Say the next line," he said.

Elena turned to look at him.

"You know it," she said.

"I know the first line of every contract I've ever cleared," Ivor said, very quietly. "I've found it in eleven hundred and forty houses. I have never — not once in four hundred years — heard anybody say it who wasn't reading it."

He put both hands flat on the table.

"Elena. Say the next line."

[End of Chapter 157]