Movement Three — Ugly When You Fight It

"You look considerably prettier," Iris said, into the quiet that had settled over the three of us, "now that you've stopped fighting it."

Vesper's whole body went taut again, instantly, the ease I'd only just felt her settle into snapping back into something sharper. "I wasn't fighting anything."

"You were," Iris said, entirely unbothered by the denial, the way she's entirely unbothered by almost everything. "You get very ugly when you fight. Your whole face closes up like a door someone's slammed. It's a shame, honestly, because you're not an ugly woman when you let it open again."

I want to tell you, because I think it's worth telling, that Vesper knew exactly what Iris was doing. She wasn't a woman easily fooled by anything, least of all a compliment shaped deliberately like an insult — she knew, the way you know the shape of a hand you've been slapped by more than once, that Iris only ever said things like that to provoke her, to watch the particular flare of temper cross her face before the temper itself had finished deciding whether it wanted to exist. Vesper knew she was pretty. She'd have told you so herself, plainly, without a shred of false modesty dressing it up, whether she happened to be furious in that particular moment or perfectly calm. Beauty had never once been the thing that frightened her.

But knowing a trap is a trap has never once, in my long experience of watching people fall into them anyway, stopped anyone from stepping directly into the center of one.

"I don't fight," Vesper said, which was, we both knew, an outright lie, the particular flat, stubborn lie of someone who has decided the truth costs more than she's currently willing to pay for it. "I simply don't enjoy being handled like a piece of furniture someone's decided to rearrange."

"You enjoy it plenty," Iris said, "you simply enjoy pretending you don't more."

I felt Vesper's whole body coil beside me, the particular gathering tension of someone preparing an argument sharp enough to actually land, and I want to admit, honestly, that I found the whole exchange considerably more entertaining than I probably should have. There is a specific pleasure, and I don't think I'll ever fully outgrow it, in watching two women who have decided, independently and for their own separate reasons, to care for each other deeply, spend their affection disguised as something closer to war. I've come to think it's simply another language, spoken fluently between the two of them, one that has never once needed translating for either party even though it would take me, on my best day, considerably longer to parse.

"At least I don't need to be told I'm beautiful every hour to remember it," Vesper said, and there was something sharper underneath that particular sentence than the ordinary rhythm of their bickering usually carried, something that landed a half-beat harder than either of them, I think, had quite intended it to.

Iris only smiled wider at that, unbothered, the particular smile of someone who has decided a wound like that simply isn't sharp enough to actually cut her. "No," she agreed, easily, "you don't. You've simply decided, instead, that no one is allowed to tell you at all, which I've always thought was a stranger trade to make."

Vesper didn't answer that one right away. I felt her jaw tighten against my shoulder, the particular held silence of someone who has run out of a comeback sharp enough to satisfy her and has decided, rather than reach for a duller one, to simply stop reaching.

Did you know this story is from NovelPhoenix? Read the official version for free and support the author.

"There's a difference," she said eventually, low, "between not needing something and not being allowed to have it."

"Is there," Iris said, not quite a question, tilting her head the way she does when she's decided a conversation has finally arrived somewhere worth staying in.

"There is," Vesper said. "One is a choice. The other is a wound someone else put there and never bothered to apologize for."

I felt her shift slightly against me as she said it, the particular small movement of someone trying to seem casual about a sentence that plainly wasn't. Iris didn't push further, not in that moment — she has always known, better than almost anyone I've met, precisely how far a particular door can be pressed before it slams shut entirely, and she let this one stay open just the width she'd already coaxed it to, rather than risk closing it by asking for more.

"Well," Iris said instead, settling back against my side with the air of someone content to let a small victory be enough for the afternoon, "you're prettier when you're not deciding it's a wound, at least."

Vesper huffed, the particular sharp exhale of someone conceding nothing out loud while conceding everything underneath it, and let the argument go.

"You two do this every time," Vesper muttered, not quite to either of us, the particular grumble of someone settling more fully into a losing position than she'd like to admit to. "Gang up. Corner me from both sides until I've got nothing left to throw back."

"We don't gang up," Iris said, entirely unrepentant. "We simply both happen to be right at the same time. It isn't our fault you keep giving us the same opening to be right about."

"That's a technicality."

"It's a fact," Iris said, "dressed in the clothes of a technicality. You're welcome to argue with the dressing if it makes you feel better."

I felt Vesper's shoulders shake, once, against my side — not quite a laugh, not something she'd have admitted to as a laugh under any direct questioning, but close enough to one that I let myself feel a small, private satisfaction at having coaxed it out of her at all. It's rare, I've come to learn, catching that particular sound loose from her before she's had the chance to swallow it back down. I've grown to treasure it precisely because of how rare it is.

I want to pause the telling here, briefly, and tell you something about how I first came to know her, because I think it matters for everything that follows, and because I don't think either of them, listening to me tell it that afternoon, minded me stopping to say it.

I met Vesper long before I ever brought her into this meadow, long before an arm around her shoulders was something either of us would have called ordinary. She found me somewhere out along the gray, unremarkable stretches of the Between she still spends most of her days wandering, offering strangers a contract in exchange for whatever small treasure her particular riddle managed to shake loose from them. Hers was never really about the treasure, I understood even then. It was about the answer itself — the one true, unguarded thing a stranger's mind reveals when it's cornered honestly enough by a question it was never prepared for.

The question she gave me, that first afternoon, was this: name one single thing that, in the whole of its existence, has never once been asked what it wants.

I remember how long I sat with it, turning the question over the way you'd turn over a stone you suspect might have something living underneath it. I remember, too, the particular quiet satisfaction that crossed her face when I finally answered — not triumph, not exactly, but the specific stillness of a woman who has just watched a stranger hand her something she hadn't expected to actually receive.

"Me," I told her.

I don't think she ever quite forgave me for that answer, if forgiveness is even the right word for whatever's happened between the two of us since. She left without giving me whatever reward she'd have offered a lesser answer, and I understood, even without her saying so, that this was itself a kind of tribute — that some answers are worth more, sitting unpaid, than any trinket she might have handed me instead.