Movement Fourteen — What the Body Confesses Before the Mind Agrees

I want to tell you something I only understood much later, turning it over across enough seasons that I finally trusted my own memory of it. Vesper's hatred was never a lie. I want to be precise about that, because I think it would be easy, telling this story badly, to make her contempt sound like some thin performance she could have dropped at any moment if she'd only chosen to. She couldn't. Hatred, for a soul like hers, wasn't a mood she was wearing. It was scaffolding — the only structure she'd found, in all her long wandering through the gray, that kept the rest of her standing upright. I don't think you tear scaffolding down gently, even when the building underneath it has already decided it no longer needs propping up.

But scaffolding was never built to feed anyone. That was the part her pride kept forgetting, and her body, apparently, had stopped forgetting a long time before she had.

I felt it happen in pieces, that first afternoon, the way you feel a held breath give out not all at once but in small, involuntary increments the lungs decide on without consulting anyone. Her shoulder blade, still sharp against my arm, softening by some fraction too small to name. Her jaw, unclenching a half-degree further with each minute that passed without me asking anything of her. I don't think she noticed the increments individually. I don't think anyone ever does, when it's their own body doing the surrendering. You only notice, afterward, that you've arrived somewhere you'd have sworn, an hour before, you had no intention of going.

Support creative writers by reading their stories on NovelPhoenix, not stolen versions.

I've come to believe there's a particular cruelty built into the architecture of the Between that most souls never say aloud, because saying it aloud would mean admitting how completely it had already won. The cold there isn't only an absence of warmth. It's a slow tax, levied on everyone equally, charged against whatever stores of self a soul managed to carry with her out of her old life. Vesper had been paying that tax for longer than most, alone, by her own choosing, and choosing it had never once made the bill smaller. I think her mind had built an entire philosophy around the idea that going without was a kind of strength. I think her body, given an actual hour of warmth for the first time in longer than pride would let her count, simply stopped listening to the philosophy at all.

That's the dissonance, I think — the falseness I warned you about before I ever let this telling begin. Not a contradiction in her character. A perfectly ordinary thing, happening to an extraordinary woman: a starving creature, offered food, will eat it before it finishes deciding whether it approves of the hand offering it. She bit me for it, later, the moment her mind caught up and remembered it was supposed to be angry. I don't think the bite undid anything the settling had already done. I think it was simply her pride, arriving late to a decision her body had already made without asking permission, and doing the only thing pride ever really knows how to do once it's lost — making the loss cost something, if only to prove it was never given away for free.

— End of Chapter —