Movement Eleven — What a Plant Cannot Give

Vesper wanted to say something. I watched the whole shape of the sentence gather behind her eyes, sharp and ready, and then watched her fall silent instead, catching sight, I think, of exactly how close I'd let myself settle against her while I finished the telling — close enough that whatever she'd been about to say lost its footing somewhere between her chest and her mouth.

Iris, beside us both, only looked between the two of us, smiled the particular soft, satisfied smile of someone who has just watched a story land exactly where she suspected it would, and let her eyes fall closed. Within moments, her breathing had settled into the slow, even rhythm of genuine sleep, curled trustingly against my side as though nothing in the whole conversation had troubled her at all — which, I suspect, nothing in it had. I've always envied that particular ability of hers, the way she can simply decide a moment has finished needing her attention and drift, unbothered, into whatever rest happens to be waiting on the other side of that decision.

The meadow settled around the two of us who remained awake, the light holding steady at that same permanent gold hour it always holds, unhurried, patient, entirely unconcerned with whatever was still unresolved between Vesper and me.

"What is it a plant can't give to everyone?" she asked. Her voice was flat, deliberate, none of the earlier sharpness dressed up as teasing anymore. "And does some philosopher out there hate him for it?"

I want to be clear that it wasn't a riddle, not the way she usually offers them, not some careful puzzle constructed to draw a stranger's fears and wants up out of hiding the way she's built her whole existence around doing. It was simply a fact, stated plainly, the way you'd state the weather, or the hour, or the precise distance between where you were standing and wherever you'd rather be instead. I recognized, underneath the flatness of it, the shape of a question she had clearly been carrying for a great deal longer than the single afternoon we'd spent together — a question that had, I suspected, followed her all the way back from the particular wound she'd never once, in all our long acquaintance, let me look at directly.

Love this story? Find the genuine version on the author's preferred platform and support their work!

I knew a little of that wound, even without her ever handing it to me plainly. I knew that she had spent a long stretch of years asking every soul she could find to define love for her, the way she'd once asked a potato-soul and an alien-soul and a nostalgic human and two silent twin silhouettes, gathering pieces of an answer the way you'd gather pieces of a shattered vessel, hoping that enough fragments, laid carefully side by side, might eventually resemble something whole. I knew that a soul at the very edge of its own unraveling had finally given her the truest version of it she ever received — that love wasn't a thing at all, but a warmth none of us can generate alone, a bridge whose only real question is whether it's still bearing weight. I knew that she had carried that answer straight back to me, once, ready to lay it at my feet, and had found me instead exactly as I always am — surrounded, warm, giving that same warmth away freely to whoever else happened to be near enough to receive it. I knew that this had broken something in her that had nothing to do with love at all, and everything to do with the particular terror of discovering that the thing she'd finally learned to want didn't come in a shape she knew how to hold onto for herself alone.

I thought of every answer I might have given her — exclusivity, perhaps, or permanence, or the specific, singular claim a person makes when they decide one soul belongs to them and no one else — and found each of them, turned over in my own head, too small and too dishonest to actually hand her.

I didn't answer right away. I want to be honest that I didn't fully know how to, not in a way that would have satisfied either of us in that moment.

But before the silence could stretch too long, another voice answered instead — low, and warm, and carrying a particular melody to it that I would have recognized blindfolded, in absolute silence, from a hundred years' distance.

"Love," Sorrel said.