Stealing Spree

The cookies and tea became a successful distraction for the three women’s questioning gazes.

Of course, that was only on the surface. Knowing Akane, she simply didn’t bother asking what we did downstairs other than ‘preparing them’. She just smirked like she already knew every filthy detail and was saving it for later.

Azusa rolled her eyes so hard I was worried they’d get stuck, pretending to be unbothered when in truth, she would find an opportunity in the future and use it as a bargaining chip.

Hanabi, my sweetest goofball, was satisfied enough with the treats. She just pulled me to her side before curling up in my embrace.

Just like this, the next twenty minutes were spent with us simply enjoying that moment.

Akane fed me the cookie while the purring goofball in my embrace asked me to feed her.

Then, Nao told the two girls she brought with her about the tea’s effect. How it would give us a good night’s sleep and we would feel energized regardless of whether we stayed up too late or not.

Once we finished the tray of cookies and emptied our teacups, it was time for the bed division.

Of course, all five of us could fit in it. It wasn’t the first time my girls slept over after all. What concerned them the most was where they would place me.

In the middle between Akane and Nao? Or perhaps, between Azusa and Hanabi?

At the edge? Or maybe they’d just pile on top of me like I was the world’s most selfish body pillow.

In the end, they didn’t even pretend to debate it fairly.

Akane simply grabbed my left wrist, Nao took my right, and before I could blink, I was being dragged to the center of the bed like a prized trophy.

Hanabi let out the tiniest, happiest squeal and dove in after me, burrowing under my left arm the second I was horizontal.

Azusa huffed something about ‘undignified’ and ‘shameless idiots’, but thirty seconds later she was sliding in on my right, pressing her face into the crook of my neck with that familiar stubborn silence that meant she wasn’t moving for anything.

Nao and Akane exchanged a look and then, with the grace of them claiming the ‘wife’ title, settled in on the outer edges.

Akane spooned Hanabi from behind, one arm draped possessively over her waist and, by extension, over me.

Nao curled against Azusa’s back, fingers threading through blonde hair like it was the most natural thing in the world and ignoring the egotistic girl’s protest.

The bed creaked once under all of us, then settled.

Five bodies. Zero personal space.

Isn’t this perfect? And looking down at Azusa and Hanabi clinging to me like they didn’t want the other two to steal me away from them, it was quite a sight.

The lights were already off, only the faint glow spilling from our window illuminated our faces.

The room smelled like the sweet cookies, the rejuvenating tea, the eucalyptus from the bath and that addicting scent of all of them on my skin.

My arms were full as they stretched out even to Nao and Akane.

Hanabi’s hair tickled my chin, while Azusa’s breath kept brushing against my collarbone.

Akane’s leg was tangling mine, slipping between Hanabi’s legs while Nao’s fingers were lazily tracing circles on Azusa’s hip using my own fingers.

I was surrounded and thoroughly locked in place. If they decided to do something before sleeping, I’d be at their mercy.

Well, I’m certain they’re all thinking about that. They’re just for everyone to fall asleep first so they could get me all to themselves.

Or was that truly the case? Honestly, it was probably different. After all, Akane and Nao wouldn’t mind demonstrating how we make love to Azusa and Hanabi.

After a few minutes of silence, Hanabi was the first to break the quiet. Her voice was sleepy and muffled against my chest.

“…We fit, babe. Hehe. I feel so comfortable here.” She whispered, like it was some kind of miracle.

“You do? Even with Akane behind you?”

“Pfft. Matsuri used to do the same when we were still sleeping on the same bed. I’m used to it.”

“Heh. Hear that, Akane? Ramp it up a bit.” I smirked and called out to the girl behind her

“Eh?”

“Got it, husband!” Lifting her head slightly, Akane put on a mischievous smirk as she moved her hand from my navel to tightly embrace Hanabi.

The goofball started wiggling but she was helplessly sandwiched between us.

In the end, all she could do was look at me for help. I leaned down to kiss her and my silly wife behind her.

Shortly after that, the two girls on my right started getting restless too.

Azusa had been pretending to be above it all, her face still buried in my neck like she was just tolerating the pile-on. But I felt it. The tiny shift of her hips, the way her thigh slid over mine under the blanket. Her breath had gone from steady to shallow, little puffs that tickled my skin.

Nao noticed it first. Her fingers, which had been lazily tracing circles on Azusa’s hip through my own hand, paused. She lifted her body slightly, just in time to catch me looking and smirked before whispering something too low for me to catch.

Whatever it was made Azusa stiffen for half a second before she let out the softest, most betrayed little scoff.

“…Shut up,” Azusa muttered. But she didn’t move away. If anything, she pressed closer, her breasts flattening against my side, one leg hooking possessively over mine like she was staking territory.

Nao just chuckled as she teasingly said. “See… Someone’s jealous she’s not the only one getting attention.”

“I’m not jealous,” Azusa snapped defensively. “… This shameless junior has already fallen for me.”

With her voice loud enough for everyone to hear, Akane and Hanabi on my left ended up looking at her as well.

Hanabi lifted her head from my chest, cheeks still flushed from Akane’s teasing embrace. “Azusa… you sound kinda cute when you’re pouty. That must be why babe loves to tease you.”

“Excuse me?” Azusa’s head snapped up, blonde hair spilling everywhere. “I do not pout.”

“You totally do,” Akane chimed in from behind Hanabi, propping her chin on Hanabi’s shoulder like this was the best show in town.

“It’s adorable. Almost as adorable as when you pretend you don’t want Ruki to notice you.”

“I never did that!” Azusa hissed.

Akane just laughed before focusing back on teasing the goofball who’s already tugging my arm shoulder to her out.

I glanced at Hanabi who was looking a little pitiful. And then to Akane, who gave me a wink before mouthing, “I’m jealous.”

I figured as much. She’s teasing Hanabi because she’s jealous.

Wait. How does that work? Obviously, it’s because she didn’t want to openly express it to the other girls. She would always try to keep herself as this unshakeable wife of mine.

As I was about to pinch Hanabi’s cheek, Azusa, in a fit of stubborn pride, rolled half on top of me. Her thigh slid right between mine, pressing up against my already half-hard cock like she was trying to win some invisible competition.

“Shameless junior, are you just going to keep silent? Help us out here!”

Do they need help? Perhaps. Against the Akane and Nao, they’re truly not going to get any upper hand from their teases. I also couldn’t confidently say I could win against them. They have already learned how to counter me, after all.

“Sorry, senpai. You can only grit your teeth or, better yet, snuggle closer. I don’t mind if I become crushed by all of you.”

“Babe, you’re a freak,” Hanabi muttered softly, throwing the word I used to call her earlier back at me.

“Ugh… This is such an awful sleepover.” Azusa grumbled but she did as I said. Not long after that, Hanabi copied her.

With my arm partially freed, I hooked it around their backs, holding her close while Nao and Akane scooted closer, sandwiching me further.

“Alright, Ruki. How are we going to sleep like this? Shouldn’t you start exhausting us?” Nao ended that with a mischievous smirk that got Azusa and Hanabi startled.

Right. I should exhaust them, right? As if… But I’ll take that advice and tone it down a little. For now.

Hanabi was already yawning a lot. And Azusa was just keeping up with her pretense of not being exhausted. The moment she went flushed against me, her whole body already relaxed.

As much as I want to spoil them more, it wouldn’t be as enjoyable if they could barely open their eyes, right? Besides, we communicated our desire for each other and we already did a lot. Hanabi even got a lot of her first taken by me. And Azusa? Almost everything.

“Nao, you’re being greedy,” Akane said as she also leaned closer to kiss me again.

“Not as greedy as you, Akane.” Nao retorted and pulled my head to her.

And with the two of them starting like that, it didn’t take long for Hanabi and Azusa to also contend for my attention.