Chapter 773: Rachel Gives Up – 'You Do the Moving'

Rachel’s hand was still wrapped tightly around the base of my cock, her chest rising and falling in heavy, uneven pants. Her face was flushed dark red, eyes glassy and conflicted.

"I can’t... take it..." she whispered, voice shaky and weak. "It’s already too much... even just like this..."

I leaned in closer, voice low and coaxing.

"Then let me do the moving. You just stay still and feel it."

Before she could argue, I gripped her hips and carefully turned her over onto her back on the cool stone floor of the cave.

Rachel immediately spread her legs in a mix of resignation and nervousness, but her hand shot down between them, covering her still-slick, slightly gaping asshole with her palm as she looked up at me with a pleading, embarrassed expression.

"You... you promise you won’t put in more than the tip... Okay? Only the tip... I’m serious..."

I nodded, though a quiet, predatory chuckle echoed in my mind.

[I’ll bury the whole thing in soon enough. Her ass is already dripping for it.]

Rachel hesitated, then spat a thick, heavy glob of saliva onto her palm and reached down to stroke it over my cock, spreading the wetness from the flushed head all the way down the thick shaft until it glistened obscenely. Her eyes stayed locked on the veined length the entire time, watching it with a mixture of fear, reluctant hunger, and deep shame.

I shifted forward on my knees, gripped the base of my cock, and tapped the swollen head lightly against her spit-soaked asshole — once, twice, three times — each soft, wet tap making her flinch and let out a tiny, nervous whimper.

Then I applied steady, relentless pressure. The tight, wrinkled ring resisted for a long second, stretching and stretching around the fat tip before finally yielding.

The entire swollen head slid inside with a wet, subtle but filthy sound.

Rachel’s back arched hard off the stone. A long, loud, completely unrestrained moan tore from her throat.

"Aaaaaaaaaah...! Fuuuck... it’s going in... nnnh... the tip is inside my ass... aah...!"

She bit down hard on her lower lip, staring with wide, glassy eyes at the place where we were joined, her voice coming out in a trembling, needy, mortified whimper as her asshole clenched and fluttered wildly around the intrusion.

"Hmm... don’t put more than that... aaah... hnnn... just the tip... only the tip... aah... it’s already stretching me so much... nnnh... my ass feels so full... aah..."

Through my mind-reading ability, her internal voice crashed into me, even more raw and embarrassed than the words she spoke out loud.

[It’s inside... the tip of his cock is inside my asshole... It’s so hot and thick... I can feel it pulsing... This is so embarrassing... My ass is being stretched open, and I’m moaning like a slut...]

[Why does it feel so good...? Why am I getting wetter...?]

I pulled back until the head almost slipped out of the tight ring, then rolled my hips forward again — this time deliberately sinking a little deeper than before.

Another thick stretch of my cock forced her asshole wider, the spit-slick walls clamping down hard. Rachel’s eyes flew open as she felt the extra girth spreading her open beyond the "tip only" rule.

"Aaaah...! It’s more than the tip... aah... you’re cheating... aaaaaaaaaah...! Pull it back... nnnh... it’s too thick... my ass can’t... aah...!"

Her inner walls immediately began pushing and squeezing in panicked, rhythmic contractions, trying to force the extra length back out.

The tight, velvety heat of her asshole rippled and milked along my cock as she actively tried to expel me. Through Mind Reading, her panicked, erotic thoughts flooded my mind without filter.

[It’s deeper than the tip... He put more in... My asshole is stretching so wide around it... This is too embarrassing... I can feel every vein... I have to push it back out... I can’t let more than the tip stay inside...]

[But it feels so full... Why am I moaning like this...? My pussy is dripping onto the floor...]

She kept clenching and pushing with her ass, managing to force my cock backward until once again only the swollen head remained buried inside the trembling ring.

Her asshole continued to spasm and squeeze around the tip in rapid, involuntary flutters while she glared up at me with watery, accusing, thoroughly embarrassed eyes, her chest heaving.

"Hnnn... aah... only the tip... I told you only the tip... nnnh... it feels so big even like this... aah... my ass is throbbing... don’t you dare put more... hnnn...!"

I exhaled a shaky, almost apologetic gasp, though the intense pleasure of her tight, pushing walls made it hard to sound sincere.

My cock throbbed hard within the clenched ring of her ass, already eager to push deeper again.

"Hmm... I can’t help it... It felt too good inside you... Your ass is so fucking tight and hot... It’s sucking me in..."

Rachel’s face burned even hotter at the vulgar praise. Another broken, embarrassed moan slipped out of her as her asshole gave another hard, involuntary squeeze around the head of my cock, still trying (and failing) to push even the tip back out while her empty, shaved pussy continued to leak clear fluid onto the stone beneath her.

[He’s saying my ass feels good... While it’s stretched around his cock... This is too shameful... But I can’t stop squeezing... It keeps trying to push him out, and it’s making those wet sounds... aah...]

My cock remained buried just past the tip inside her, throbbing hard against her desperate, pushing walls while Rachel lay beneath me, panting and trembling, still trying — and slowly failing — to enforce the "only the tip" rule she was rapidly losing control over.

I leaned forward and captured her mouth in a deep, hungry kiss, deliberately blocking her view of how much of my cock was actually sinking into her ass.

At the same time I reached up with one hand, squeezed her soft breast firmly, and began teasing the stiff nipple between my fingers — pinching, rolling, and tugging it while my tongue slid against hers.

Rachel’s protest melted into a long, muffled moan against my lips.

"Aaaaaaaaaah... mmph... this... is... hnnn... this is clearly not just the tip... pull out... aah..."

Even as she said it, her asshole clenched and fluttered around the extra thickness I had already taken, and her empty, shaved pussy continued to leak clear fluid onto the stone beneath us.

Her hands came up to my shoulders, half-pushing, half-clinging, while I kept her distracted with the deep kiss and the relentless teasing of her sensitive nipple, slowly rolling my hips to feed just a little more of my cock into the scorching tightness of her ass.