Chapter 726: The Big Sister’s Dark Past

"Ahhh... fuck..." I groaned, instinctively resting a hand on the back of Eli’s head as she kept sucking and cleaning every last drop from my cock. I couldn’t believe how hungry and shameless she was, drinking my cum right in front of June without even a second of shame or restraint.

"Eli... don’t be so greedy. Save some for me," Donna called out the moment she saw Eli greedily taking every last drop of my cum into her mouth.

"You love it that much, huh?" I asked, still resting my hand on the back of Eli’s head, feeling how eagerly she kept sucking and swallowing around my cock.

Eli finally pulled her lips off with a wet, obscene sound. She tilted her head back, opened her mouth wide, and showed both of us her tongue completely coated in a thick, creamy pool of my semen. She played with it slowly, letting the heavy cum stretch between her tongue and the roof of her mouth, making sure June could see every filthy detail.

Then, right in front of our eyes, and especially in front of June’s shocked stare, she closed her lips and swallowed everything in one long, greedy gulp. She didn’t leave even a single drop to share with anyone.

"You got fucked in the ass, Donna," Eli said with a small, satisfied smile as she wiped the corner of her mouth with her thumb. "And I drank his cum. It’s fair."

"You’re so greedy, Eli... I really hate you," Donna replied, though her voice carried more playful jealousy than real anger. Her eyes were still glassy from the rough fucking she had just taken.

"It was so tasty, Alex," Eli murmured, wrapping her warm fingers around my still-hard, cum-slick cock and giving it a slow, appreciative stroke from base to tip. The thick shaft remained stiff and heavily veined, looking almost obscene resting in her mature hand. "I hope you still have more for us."

June hadn’t looked away for even a second. Her eyes were locked on my cock with an intensity that surprised me. Even though she was an innocent woman in her thirties who had grown up on this island, I could tell from her expression that she had probably never seen a cock like mine up close in her entire life, thick, heavy, glistening, and still throbbing after unloading so much cum onto two older women.

Eli clearly noticed the stare as well. She leaned in again, dragged her wet tongue slowly over the sensitive, swollen head of my cock, and looked straight at June with dark invitation in her eyes.

"June... why don’t we share Alex?" she offered in a soft, almost sweet voice. "I’m sure you want some too."

"No, Aunt Eli... I don’t..." June answered quickly, her cheeks flushing as she took a small step backward.

"Oh, come on, June," Donna cut in, her tone sharper and more direct now. She had recovered enough strength to turn around fully and sit up on her knees, her heavy, pale breasts hanging freely and swaying with the movement. "We all know why you never actually married your fiancé. You’re not a little girl anymore. Stop pretending."

I looked at June. The expression on her face made it painfully clear that Donna had just exposed something she had been trying hard to keep buried.

"She had a fiancé?" I asked, turning toward Donna.

"Yeah, Alex," Donna replied with a small, knowing smile. She glanced at June as if she knew exactly what the younger woman had been hiding all these years. "She was about to marry the love of her life when she came of age."

"It’s not like that, Aunt Donna," June said quickly, her voice tight. She still couldn’t bring herself to meet my eyes.

"Then why don’t you marry him now?" Donna continued, her tone light but sharp enough to cut. "He’s still in love with you. Well... what could he even do? No woman on this island would marry him." She looked over at Eli as she spoke, and both older women shared a quiet, understanding little smile.

"So that means he doesn’t get...?" I started to ask, but the way June’s expression crumpled made it clear the interrogation was pushing her close to tears.

"It doesn’t matter why I didn’t marry him, Aunt Donna," June said, forcing her voice to stay steady. She turned to me with that same protective, big-sister look she had always used when she thought I was making a mistake. "But what you’re doing here is so wrong. Alex, you’re coming with me right now."

Eli clearly had other plans. She leaned back on the wooden floor of the shack, folded her legs up toward her chest, and spread her thighs wide open so I could get a full, unobstructed view of her mature, tanned pussy.

The soft outer lips were already shiny with arousal. Without any hesitation she reached down with both hands and spread herself open, showing me the wet, pink inside of her hole like an open invitation.

My cock twitched hard at the sight.

"Alex, come with me," June repeated, her voice tighter now.

"Alex... don’t you want to feel how warm it is inside?" Eli purred, her dark eyes locked on mine with pure hunger. "Ahhh... just the tip, please... the moment you feel it you’ll know."

Her words were pure, practiced seduction, and they were working far too well. I couldn’t look away from the open, dripping entrance of her pussy. The soft folds glistened under the afternoon light.

Without saying a single word to either of them, I moved forward on my knees. I gripped the thick base of my cock, lined the swollen head up, and pressed it right against Eli’s mature, soaking entrance. I rubbed it slowly up and down, coating the fat tip in her warm juices, feeling how easily she would take me.

"Ahhh... right there... shove it in, Alex... it’s so warm inside..." Eli moaned, her voice thick and needy as she kept herself spread open for me.

June stood frozen a few steps away, completely silent. She watched with wide, disbelieving eyes as I rubbed my rock-hard, massive cock against the dripping pussy of an older woman she had always called "Aunt." Her gaze never left the filthy sight for even a second.