Knowledge Is Power: The Last Reader

Chapter 198: The Hands on the Lever

  • Next Chapter

The hearing was scheduled for the following Tuesday.

Aria spent the days before it doing something she disliked.

She waited.

Not because she lacked work. New Beginning had plenty. The second kiln needed repairs, the cooperative’s first transport arrangements required supervision, and three merchants had requested revised delivery dates after the Northbank disruption.

But the question she wanted answered could not be solved by inspecting another warehouse or correcting another capacity register.

Who controlled the movement of goods through the region?

She had a map.

What she didn’t have was a complete picture of the authority behind it.

On Monday evening, Lucan arrived with a thick folder.

"I think I’ve found something."

Aria looked up from the council accounts.

"Something useful?"

"Unfortunately."

Kelme, who was sorting invoices nearby, raised his head.

"Why unfortunately?"

"Because useful things usually create more work."

"Then throw it away."

Lucan placed the folder on the table.

"The Eastern Corridor Materials Exchange isn’t simply a storage facility. It’s a coordination network. It manages booking windows, warehouse availability, transport slots, and priority classifications for several regional suppliers."

Aria opened the folder.

"Who operates it?"

"A private management company under a contract with the Regional Authority."

"Who owns the warehouses?"

"Different companies. Some are independent. Others have financial relationships with the same investment groups."

"Who owns the transport companies?"

"Again, different owners. But the exchange coordinates their access to certain routes and loading facilities."

Aria turned a page.

"So the exchange doesn’t own the entire system."

"No. It controls several important points within it."

Kelme leaned forward.

"Meaning?"

Lucan pointed at the diagram.

"Imagine five warehouses. They belong to five separate businesses. But all five use the same booking system to access a major loading terminal. If the system changes their priority, they may all experience the same delay, even though their owners are independent."

Aria studied the diagram.

"And if the exchange suspends a booking?"

"The warehouse might still have stock. The carrier might still have a vehicle. The buyer might still have a contract. But the shipment cannot move through that terminal at the scheduled time."

Kelme sat back.

"So the goods exist, the customers exist, the roads exist..."

"And the delivery still fails," Aria finished.

She closed the folder.

"That’s our next problem."

Lucan nodded.

"There’s another detail. The exchange has a priority classification called Regional Continuity Status. Facilities receiving it get preferred access to certain transport slots during declared disruptions."

"Who grants it?"

"The Authority approves the classification. The exchange implements it."

"And who reviews the decisions?"

"An internal committee."

"Independent?"

Lucan hesitated.

"Not entirely. The committee includes representatives from the Authority and the exchange’s management company."

Aria looked toward the window.

"So the same arrangement that allocates priority also reviews complaints about that allocation."

"That’s how it appears."

She made a note.

It wasn’t proof of corruption. It wasn’t even necessarily proof of bad administration.

But it was a structure that deserved examination.

The hearing took place in the regional administrative hall.

The room was larger than the one used by the Continuity Working Group. Representatives from the Authority sat at the front, while merchants, workshop owners, transport operators, and local officials occupied the rows behind them.

Elira Voss was present, alongside Cassian Vale and Halden.

At the center of the panel sat Magistrate Orven.

To his right was a woman Aria had not met before.

"Director Veyna," Perrin whispered. "She oversees the Materials Exchange."

Aria looked at her.

Veyna was in her forties, neatly dressed, and completely absorbed in the documents before her. She didn’t look particularly intimidating.

That made Aria more cautious, not less.

People who managed complicated systems rarely needed to raise their voices.

Magistrate Orven opened the hearing.

"We are gathered to examine the continuity of critical regional suppliers and the infrastructure that supports them. Recent disruptions have exposed weaknesses in processing, transport, and allocation."

He looked toward the representatives.

"We must determine whether existing voluntary arrangements are sufficient, or whether additional obligations are required."

A merchant spoke first.

He argued that the Authority needed broader emergency powers to redirect transport and materials quickly.

A warehouse operator disagreed.

He explained that unexpected reallocations could leave warehouses holding goods for which they had no confirmed buyers, while existing customers suffered contractual losses.

A transport representative raised another issue.

"Priority classifications are useful," he said, "but they become meaningless when the system assigns more priority shipments than the available carriers can actually move."

Cassian wrote something down.

Aria watched the panel.

Everyone was describing a different part of the same machine.

Eventually, Orven turned to Director Veyna.

"Can you explain how the Materials Exchange operates during an emergency?"

Veyna stood.

"Certainly. The exchange coordinates available storage and transport capacity across participating facilities. During ordinary conditions, customers reserve services according to commercial agreements. During a declared regional disruption, priority classifications may be applied to ensure that essential goods reach designated destinations."

"Who determines which goods are essential?"

"The Authority provides the applicable classification."

"And who determines whether the transport capacity exists?"

"The exchange evaluates available routes, carriers, loading slots, and warehouse capacity."

"Does it distinguish between confirmed and estimated capacity?"

"Yes."

Aria looked at Lucan.

He gave a small nod.

That was encouraging.

Orven continued.

"Can the exchange guarantee delivery once a shipment receives priority?"

"No," Veyna replied. "We coordinate the available resources. We cannot guarantee that a road remains open, a vehicle remains operational, or a shipment is ready for collection."

"Then what exactly does priority guarantee?"

Veyna paused.

"It guarantees that the shipment receives consideration before lower-priority bookings when allocation decisions are made."

Aria wrote the sentence down.

Consideration.

Not delivery.

Not a vehicle.

Not a guaranteed time.

Just consideration.

Orven turned to the next witness.

Aria waited until her name was called.

She stood with her notes in one hand.

"New Beginning has participated in the regional continuity arrangements for several months," she began. "We have supplied emergency goods, reserved storage space under a voluntary agreement, and joined the Regional Manufacturing Cooperative."

Orven nodded.

"We are aware of your participation."

"During that time, we’ve discovered that several businesses considered independent rely on the same processing facilities, transport routes, warehouses, or booking systems. Their ownership may be separate, but their operational dependencies overlap."

Veyna listened without interrupting.

Aria continued.

"The Authority has correctly identified the need to distinguish actual production from theoretical production. I believe the same distinction is necessary for transport and storage."

"Explain," Orven said.

"A warehouse may have space, but that doesn’t mean the space is suitable for every material. A carrier may have vehicles, but that doesn’t mean those vehicles are available for every route. A booking system may show a priority slot, but that doesn’t mean a vehicle can reach the loading point."

She placed a diagram on the table.

"This is a simplified example of our dependencies."

Orven examined it.

"What does the red line represent?"

"A shared booking system. Three warehouses use different transport companies, but all three rely on the same exchange to schedule access to the main loading terminal."

"So a disruption to the exchange could affect all three?"

"Yes."

Veyna leaned forward.

"That is technically correct, but the exchange has contingency procedures."

Aria turned toward her.

"Could you explain them?"

"Certainly. If the primary booking system becomes unavailable, we can activate manual scheduling through the regional operations office."

"How long does activation take?"

"Under normal circumstances, several hours."

"And how many shipments can be processed manually?"

"That depends on staffing and the volume of requests."

"Is there a verified maximum?"

Veyna paused.

"We have an estimated figure."

Aria waited.

Veyna looked down at her papers.

"I would need to confirm the latest operational assessment."

Aria nodded.

"That’s reasonable. I would ask that the Authority distinguish between estimated manual capacity and tested manual capacity in its continuity records."

Cassian made another note.

Orven leaned back.

"Are you suggesting that the exchange itself should be subject to mandatory continuity requirements?"

"Yes."

The room became quieter.

Aria continued before anyone could misunderstand her.

"But those requirements should be proportionate to its actual responsibilities. The exchange should document its critical systems, maintain tested alternatives where feasible, establish procedures for outages, and communicate disruptions to affected users."

"And if it fails to do so?" Orven asked.

"Then there should be a review, corrective measures, and appropriate consequences under the governing contract or law."

"Would you support compulsory backup systems?"

"If an assessment establishes that the service is sufficiently critical, that a backup is technically feasible, and that the cost is proportionate to the public risk."

Orven nodded slowly.

"And should the Authority be allowed to direct the allocation of transport capacity during emergencies?"

Aria looked at Veyna, then back at the magistrate.

"Only within defined limits. The Authority should identify the emergency purpose, the goods concerned, the period of intervention, and the criteria used to determine priority. Existing contracts should not disappear simply because a classification changes."

Halden shifted in his chair.

"Emergencies do not always allow lengthy procedures."

"Agreed," Aria said. "But a short procedure is not the same as no procedure."

She turned to him.

"A temporary allocation decision can be made quickly and reviewed afterward. What matters is that the reason is recorded, the affected parties are informed, and the decision can be challenged if it was based on incorrect information."

Halden looked unconvinced.

"Suppose a water station is running out of essential supplies. Would you delay a shipment because a merchant objects to losing a transport slot?"

"No. I would ask whether the shipment can be redirected without creating another serious shortage, whether an alternative route exists, and how the affected merchant will be compensated if the intervention causes a loss."

"And if there is no alternative?"

"Then the Authority may need to act. But the absence of an alternative should be demonstrated, not assumed."

For a moment, nobody spoke.

Then Orven thanked her and invited the next witness.

Aria returned to her seat.

Kelme leaned toward her.

"You didn’t insult anyone."

"I wasn’t trying to."

"Progress."

The most difficult part of the hearing came after lunch.

A representative of the Materials Exchange presented a diagram showing the Authority’s emergency allocation process.

It was clean, efficient, and reassuring.

Requests entered the system.

The Authority assigned priority classifications.

The exchange allocated available transport and storage.

Deliveries were recorded.

Disputes were reviewed afterward.

The diagram contained arrows, boxes, and a final section marked COMPLETED DELIVERY.

Aria studied it.

Then she noticed something.

She raised her hand.

"Director Veyna, may I ask about the final stage?"

"Certainly."

"The diagram shows a shipment moving from allocation to completed delivery. What happens if the exchange allocates a transport slot, but the carrier cannot collect the goods?"

"The booking is adjusted."

"And if the carrier has already accepted another contract?"

"Then the carrier may request a revised allocation."

"And if the warehouse cannot release the goods because they are already committed to another buyer?"

"That would be addressed through the emergency allocation process."

"By whom?"

"The relevant Authority department."

"Would the existing buyer be notified?"

"Yes."

"Would the buyer receive compensation?"

"That depends on the circumstances and the applicable agreement."

Aria looked at the diagram again.

"Then the final box should not say completed delivery. It should say allocated transport, pending confirmation of goods and carrier availability."

A few people in the room shifted.

Veyna examined the document.

"That is a fair correction."

Aria continued.

"There are three separate decisions here. The Authority decides what should receive priority. The exchange decides how available transport and storage are allocated. The supplier decides whether the goods are ready and can legally be released, unless a valid emergency direction overrides that decision."

Cassian nodded.

"And those decisions may involve different departments."

"Exactly. If the process treats them as one decision, everyone assumes someone else has confirmed the missing details."

Veyna took a pen and marked the diagram.

"We can revise that."

Aria sat back.

It was a small correction.

But small corrections mattered when an entire system depended on them.

At the end of the hearing, Magistrate Orven announced that the board would prepare a draft framework for critical infrastructure continuity.

The framework would consider:

* Maintenance and operational risk reporting.

* Tested backup procedures for critical coordination systems.

* Clear definitions of available transport and storage capacity.

* Published emergency allocation criteria.

* Notification and review procedures.

* Compensation where emergency intervention caused qualifying commercial losses.

He also announced a separate review of the Materials Exchange’s manual backup system.

No new compulsory production quotas would be introduced through the infrastructure framework.

Aria considered that a useful distinction.

As the representatives began leaving, Veyna approached her.

"Miss Aria?"

Aria turned.

"Director."

"I wanted to discuss your diagram."

"Of course."

Veyna held up the document.

"You’ve identified a weakness in how we present our operational capacity. We have several systems that can function independently, but we have not tested how they perform together during a large disruption."

"Then the region may be more dependent on the exchange than its current assessment suggests."

"Possibly. I would like to invite the cooperative to participate in a practical continuity exercise."

Aria looked at Perrin.

He seemed interested.

"What would the exercise involve?" she asked.

"We would simulate the loss of the primary booking system. The exchange would switch to manual scheduling, and participating warehouses and carriers would respond to a controlled set of requests."

"Would actual shipments be affected?"

"No. It would be a simulation."

"Would the results be published?"

"We could publish a summary."

"Would participating businesses receive the full findings?"

"Yes."

"Would the exercise be used to assign additional obligations to participants?"

Veyna gave her a measured look.

"I cannot promise that no future policy will consider the findings. But participation itself would not constitute consent to additional obligations."

Aria nodded.

"Then we can discuss it."

Veyna offered her hand.

"Good. I think we could learn something from this."

Aria shook it.

"I hope so."

That evening, New Beginning’s council reviewed the invitation.

Martha was cautious.

"We’re already involved in the manufacturing cooperative. Do we need to involve ourselves in the exchange’s problems as well?"

"We depend on it," Aria replied.

"But we don’t control it."

"Exactly."

Lucan opened the dependency map.

"If the booking system fails, our alternative carrier may still have vehicles, but we could lose access to the main loading terminal. We’d need to use a different route or facility."

"Can we?"

"Possibly. I haven’t verified the capacity."

Yara looked at him.

"You’ve become very careful with that word."

"Aria has made it expensive to use casually."

Kelme nodded.

"It’s now a luxury word. Only approved officials may say it."

Martha ignored them.

"What would the exercise cost us?"

Perrin explained that the cooperative would be asked to provide a limited number of simulated shipments and staff hours. No actual goods would move, and participants would be reimbursed for reasonable expenses.

The council discussed the proposal.

There were concerns about sharing operational data, the possibility of the exercise becoming a justification for new regulations, and the time required from workers already managing the pottery business.

Aria proposed a limited participation agreement.

New Beginning would provide only the information necessary to test its booking and delivery procedures. Customer identities and private commercial terms would remain confidential. Participation would not authorize the exchange to change existing contracts or claim additional capacity.

The council approved participation, subject to the written agreement.

After the meeting, Martha remained behind.

"You know," she said, "there was a time when our biggest concern was whether we could sell enough bowls to pay for the workshop."

Aria smiled faintly.

"I remember."

"Now we’re discussing the resilience of a regional logistics system."

"It’s a strange improvement."

Martha gathered the papers.

"Do you ever miss having smaller problems?"

"Sometimes."

"Then why keep taking on larger ones?"

Aria looked toward the workshop.

"Because the larger problems eventually reach the smaller ones. If the transport system fails, our pottery orders don’t matter. If the clay processor stops, our kilns don’t matter. If the Authority reallocates materials without understanding existing contracts, our agreements don’t protect us."

She paused.

"I’d rather understand the system before it decides our future for us."

Martha nodded.

"Just remember that understanding it doesn’t mean you have to carry it."

Aria looked at her.

That was perhaps the most useful advice anyone had given her all week.

Two days later, the first documents for the continuity exercise arrived.

Perrin brought them to the workshop, where Aria reviewed the proposed scenarios.

The first simulated the loss of the primary booking system.

The second simulated a road closure.

The third simulated a warehouse becoming unavailable.

The fourth combined all three.

Aria frowned at the final scenario.

"Why would they combine them?"

"Because separate failures are manageable," Perrin said. "The exercise is meant to test how the system behaves when several problems happen together."

She continued reading.

The scenario assumed that the primary booking system would fail during a period of unusually high demand, while a major road was closed and one regional warehouse was unavailable.

The exchange would have to prioritize emergency shipments, coordinate alternative carriers, and allocate storage space across the remaining facilities.

Aria looked at the list of participating businesses.

New Beginning was included.

So were Northbank, two warehouses, four transport companies, and several merchants.

Then she noticed a familiar name.

Veyr Regional Logistics.

Lucan had previously identified the company as part of the wider network connected to Silas Veyr’s financial interests.

Aria read the entry again.

"Is this the company that handles the northern transport contracts?"

Lucan, who had arrived with Perrin, looked at the page.

"Yes."

"Do they control the alternative route?"

"Not entirely. But they operate the largest carrier group in that corridor."

"Do they have a financial relationship with the exchange?"

"They provide transport services under a long-term contract."

Aria placed the document down.

"Then the exercise may reveal whether the region has an alternative to the same network it already depends on."

Perrin nodded.

"That’s the point."

"Who designed the combined scenario?"

"The exchange, with input from Cassian’s department."

Aria returned to the first page.

There was a final section at the bottom.

EXERCISE CONTROL AND FINAL ALLOCATION AUTHORITY: REGIONAL MATERIALS EXCHANGE.

She stared at it.

"Perrin?"

"Yes?"

"Who decides which simulated shipments receive priority?"

"The exchange."

"And who decides whether the exercise has been successful?"

"The exchange reports the results. The Authority reviews them."

"Can participants challenge the results?"

Perrin checked the document.

"I don’t see a procedure for that."

Aria slowly closed the folder.

The exercise was supposed to test the system.

But the system itself would control the test, make the decisions, and report whether it had succeeded.

It was not necessarily dishonest.

It was simply incomplete.

She reached for her pen.

"We need an independent observer."

Perrin nodded.

"And a separate record of what each participant actually receives, not just what the exchange allocates."

"Yes."

"And the exercise should include a situation where the exchange itself is unavailable. Otherwise, we’re testing whether the exchange can operate during an emergency, not whether the region can function without it."

Lucan leaned closer.

"That would be difficult."

"Which is why we need to test it."

She added another note.

FAILURE OF THE COORDINATING AUTHORITY ITSELF.

For several seconds, the room was quiet.

Then Kelme, who had been reading over her shoulder, spoke.

"That’s a rather uncomfortable scenario."

Aria capped her pen.

"It’s supposed to be."

Outside, the evening carts began returning from the road. The settlement’s workshops were closing, their workers heading home, their orders still intact.

Aria looked at the map on the wall.

She had spent months learning how a community could remain independent while participating in a larger economy.

Now she was beginning to understand the next problem.

A network could be decentralized in ownership and still centralized in control.

Five independent workshops could rely on one processor.

Four transport companies could depend on one booking system.

Ten warehouses could follow the decisions of one exchange.

And a system that coordinated everyone could become the one thing nobody knew how to replace.

Aria wrote one final sentence beneath the new scenario.

A resilient network must survive the failure of its coordinator.

Then she turned to Perrin.

"Let’s see whether the Authority is willing to test that."

Perrin gathered the documents.

"And if they refuse?"

Aria glanced at the map.

"Then we’ll have learned something before the exercise even begins."

If you find any errors (non-standard content, ads redirect, broken links, etc..), Please let us know so we can fix it as soon as possible.

Report

Use arrow keys (or A / D) to PREV/NEXT chapter