Knowledge Is Power: The Last Reader

Chapter 188: The Power to Decide

  • Next Chapter

Aria had written the same question at the top of three different sheets of paper.

What exactly can the Authority force us to do?

The first sheet contained questions about emergency production orders.

The second covered storage, materials, and existing contracts.

The third was mostly empty, except for one sentence she had written so hard that the pen had nearly torn through the paper.

Who decides when an emergency is over?

She stared at it.

Then she turned toward Kelme.

"Do you know what happens when an emergency lasts long enough?"

Kelme was sitting across the council table, attempting to repair a broken buckle with a knife, a piece of wire, and an amount of confidence that worried everyone who witnessed it.

"People become accustomed to it?"

"Correct."

"Excellent. I shall now become accustomed to being unable to fasten my belt."

Aria ignored him.

"When an emergency begins, people accept temporary measures because they want the problem solved. But if nobody defines when those measures end, temporary powers can become permanent habits."

Kelme examined the buckle.

"Then we should define when this conversation ends."

"Now would be good."

"Wonderful. Progress."

Aria gathered her papers.

The regional Authority had corrected its instructions about capacity estimates. Suppliers would no longer be judged solely by theoretical maximum output. That was a meaningful improvement.

But the correction had revealed a larger problem.

The Authority possessed several different emergency powers, scattered across regulations written at different times. Some covered materials allocation. Others governed strategic facilities, public supply, or emergency requisition. Their boundaries overlapped, and their definitions were not always consistent.

Nobody had yet assembled them into one clear explanation.

Aria intended to change that.

By midday, she had requested copies of every regulation cited in the Authority’s recent notices.

By the following morning, she had received eleven documents, three outdated summaries, and a polite letter informing her that one of the requested regulations was available only for consultation at the regional archive.

Kelme read the letter.

"They have given us eleven documents and hidden the twelfth."

"They haven’t hidden it. They say we have to consult it in person."

"Ah. The traditional administrative technique of making knowledge physically inconvenient."

"Get your coat."

"Why?"

"We’re going to the archive."

Kelme put down the letter.

"I knew I should have stayed a criminal."

The regional archive occupied two floors of an old stone building behind the Authority’s main office.

Its reading room smelled of dust, leather, and the quiet suffering of people who had spent their careers cataloguing documents nobody wanted to read.

A clerk led Aria to a long table and brought out the relevant regulation.

It was older than she expected.

The document established emergency supply powers during periods of regional shortage. It permitted temporary orders directing certain businesses to provide specified goods, provided the orders followed the procedures described in the regulation.

Aria read the section carefully.

Then she read it again.

"Kelme."

He had found a comfortable chair and was already halfway through a pamphlet about regional taxation.

"If this is about the buckle, I refuse to discuss it without legal representation."

"Listen to this."

She read the relevant passage aloud.

The Authority could issue an emergency supply directive when a designated shortage threatened essential regional services. The directive had to identify the goods required, the receiving authority, the delivery deadline, and the basis for the order. Payment was to be determined under the applicable emergency valuation rules.

Kelme lowered his pamphlet.

"That sounds more specific than the recent notices."

"It is."

"Then what is the problem?"

"The regulation says the business must be notified of the order. It doesn’t clearly explain how a business challenges an order that relies on incorrect capacity information."

"Perhaps the other regulation explains it."

"That one explains how to challenge the valuation."

"So there are two procedures."

"And neither one clearly addresses the situation where the Authority orders more than the business can produce."

Kelme considered this.

"Then the problem isn’t that they have no rules. It’s that the rules don’t fit together."

"Exactly."

She made a note.

The regulation did not give the Authority unlimited power. It established conditions, procedures, and payment requirements. But its language left unanswered questions about how those conditions applied to a small community such as New Beginning.

Was the settlement a collection of individual businesses?

Was its shared pottery storage facility a strategic asset?

Could the Authority impose obligations on the community itself, even when the businesses involved had separate contracts and separate owners?

And could an emergency directive override those private agreements without explaining why?

Aria wrote each question down.

Then she found something else.

A section near the end of the regulation required emergency measures to be reviewed when the conditions that justified them changed.

She stopped reading.

"That’s important."

Kelme leaned over.

"Why?"

"Because they need a reason to continue using emergency powers after the circumstances change."

"Does the regulation say how often they must review them?"

Aria searched the following pages.

"No."

"Of course it doesn’t."

"It says the measures must be reviewed. It doesn’t specify a deadline, who must conduct the review, or what happens if nobody does."

Kelme returned to his pamphlet.

"I would like to submit a formal complaint against this document."

"For what?"

"Encouraging you."

She smiled despite herself.

For the first time since the assessment notice arrived, Aria felt she had found something more useful than another disagreement.

She had found a question the Authority would have to answer.

Not whether New Beginning was useful.

Not whether the region needed reliable suppliers.

But whether emergency obligations could continue indefinitely without a fresh justification.

She copied the relevant passages and requested certified extracts.

Then she went looking for the regulations governing strategic facilities.

Cassian Vale met them that afternoon.

He had agreed to review Aria’s findings before the next working-group session, though he warned her that the legal department might interpret some provisions differently.

Aria placed her notes in front of him.

"I want to understand the legal basis for each potential obligation before we discuss what New Beginning should accept."

Cassian read the first page.

"That is reasonable."

"Then let’s start with designation. What criteria allow the Authority to classify a business or community as strategically significant?"

"Regional impact, supply concentration, transport access, and the availability of alternatives."

"Are there minimum thresholds?"

"Not consistently across all categories."

"Can two businesses with similar output receive different classifications?"

"Potentially, if their circumstances differ."

"What prevents the decision from being arbitrary?"

Cassian put down the papers.

"Evidence, recorded reasons, review, and appeal."

"Are those mandatory in every case?"

He hesitated.

"Not in precisely the same form."

Aria nodded and wrote that down.

She wasn’t trying to trap him. She wanted the uncertainty recorded.

"Next question. If a community is designated, what obligations follow automatically?"

"Designation can trigger reporting requirements and continuity planning. Additional production or storage obligations depend on the applicable regulation or a separate order."

"So designation doesn’t automatically authorize every possible demand?"

"Correct."

"Then the notice should say that."

Cassian considered the point.

"It would help if the distinction were explicit."

"Would you support adding it?"

"I can recommend it."

Aria turned to the next page.

"Now the emergency directive. If the Authority orders a quantity that exceeds verified capacity, who is responsible for establishing that the quantity is achievable?"

"The issuing department must use the information reasonably available to it."

"Does that mean the supplier has to prove impossibility after the order is issued?"

"Not necessarily."

"Then the procedure needs to say what happens when the figures conflict."

Cassian rubbed his forehead.

"You are asking us to solve several problems at once."

"They are several problems. That’s why people keep getting trapped between them."

He looked at her for a moment, then laughed quietly.

"Fair enough."

He took a fresh sheet of paper.

"Let’s divide your concerns into three categories. First, designation criteria. Second, the powers available after designation. Third, the review and appeal process for individual orders."

"And emergency duration."

"That belongs in the third category."

"It deserves its own line."

He added it.

Aria leaned back.

The meeting was going better than she had expected.

Cassian wasn’t promising her everything she wanted, but he wasn’t pretending the gaps didn’t exist. He could distinguish a legal question from a political preference, and he seemed willing to put difficult questions in front of the people who could answer them.

That was progress.

It was also dangerous to mistake progress for protection.

Before they left, Cassian gave her a copy of the preliminary assessment template.

Most of it was ordinary administrative material.

One section caught her attention.

Assessment of Regional Consequences if Operations Are Interrupted.

Beneath it were spaces for estimated losses, affected customers, alternative suppliers, and recovery time.

At the bottom, someone had added a new question.

Estimated time required for the Authority to establish substitute supply.

Aria read it twice.

"Who added this?"

Cassian checked the revision note.

"The working group. It came from a suggestion submitted after the public session."

"Do we know who submitted it?"

He turned the page.

The contributor was listed as the Regional Continuity Office.

Aria tapped the question.

"This changes the assessment."

"How?"

"It forces the Authority to measure its own ability to respond. If New Beginning stops producing, they can’t just record how much pottery disappears. They also have to estimate how long it would take to replace us."

"That’s the purpose."

"And if the answer is that they have no alternative?"

"Then the region has identified a vulnerability."

"Or an excuse to impose obligations on us."

Cassian didn’t deny it.

"It could be used either way. That’s why the assessment needs safeguards."

Aria took the template.

"Then let’s make sure the report includes the cost of creating alternatives, not only the cost of losing us."

Back in New Beginning, Martha had gathered the council around the largest table in the settlement.

Aria explained the distinction between designation, operational orders, and emergency review.

The council listened closely.

"So they can classify us without automatically controlling everything we do?" one member asked.

"That’s how Cassian interprets the current framework. But designation can still trigger reporting and continuity requirements, and separate emergency powers may apply."

"Which means we might spend years answering reports while they gradually add obligations."

"Possibly," Aria said. "That’s why we need to challenge vague requirements before they become routine."

Martha studied the assessment template.

"The substitute-supply question is useful. If they have to calculate how long replacement would take, they may realize the region needs more suppliers."

"Exactly."

"And what if they decide the easiest way to guarantee supply is to require us to produce a minimum amount every month?"

"Then we ask how that minimum was calculated, whether the materials exist, how much it costs, and what happens when the kiln breaks."

Kelme raised a hand.

"And who pays for the kiln when it breaks?"

"The Authority, if the applicable agreement or order provides for that compensation."

"What if it doesn’t?"

"Then we negotiate the terms or challenge the order if it violates the applicable rules."

Kelme lowered his hand.

"I miss the days when our problems could be solved with a good hiding place and a locked door."

"You complained about the cave every day," Martha reminded him.

"I complained about the cave. I did not complain about the simplicity of the cave."

Aria spread her documents across the table.

"We have seven days to answer the assessment notice. I want three things in our response."

She wrote them down.

First: A verified account of what New Beginning actually produces, including existing commitments and available surplus.

Second: A continuity proposal showing what we can reasonably provide voluntarily, with clear costs and limits.

Third: A request for the legal criteria, review schedule, and appeal procedure that would apply if we were designated.

Martha added a fourth item.

"What the Authority must do to reduce the region’s dependence on us."

Aria nodded and wrote it beneath the others.

"Good."

One of the council members frowned.

"Won’t that make us sound unwilling to help?"

"No. It will make us sound willing to help responsibly."

She looked around the table.

"We can offer reserved storage, planned emergency supply, and reliable reporting. We can cooperate with other suppliers. We can help the region build backup routes and identify shortages before they become crises."

She paused.

"But we cannot promise unlimited production. We cannot accept orders based on imaginary capacity. And we cannot build a future around the assumption that our workers, materials, and kilns will never fail."

The room was quiet.

Then Martha nodded.

"Put that in the response."

Three days later, the regional working group convened.

This time, the room contained more than officials.

Harlan Marlow represented the clay suppliers. Tessa Vale attended for the small construction workshops. Selene Ward represented Northmark Materials. Lucan sat among the commercial representatives, while Aria and Martha represented New Beginning.

Halden opened the session with a warning.

"The region cannot guarantee continuity through voluntary agreements alone. Some emergencies require compulsory measures."

Nobody disputed that outright.

Aria raised her hand.

"The question is what limits those measures must observe."

Halden nodded reluctantly.

The discussion moved through reporting, confidentiality, capacity definitions, and the proposed registry. Several of Selene’s safeguards were accepted in principle. The Authority would distinguish verified output from theoretical capacity, define access to confidential records, and establish a process for correcting disputed figures.

Then the group turned to strategic designation.

A representative from the Regional Continuity Office presented three possible approaches.

The first would impose mandatory reporting on designated businesses.

The second would require designated businesses to maintain approved continuity plans.

The third would allow specific production or storage obligations to be imposed when justified by an emergency.

Halden favored retaining all three.

Aria studied the proposal.

"Are these three separate decisions?"

"They are three elements of a broader framework," the representative answered.

"That wasn’t my question. Can a business be required to report without being required to maintain reserved capacity?"

"Yes."

"Can it maintain a continuity plan without accepting a minimum production quota?"

"Yes, depending on the final regulation."

"Can a production obligation be imposed without designation?"

"In some circumstances, under existing emergency powers."

Aria nodded.

"Then the framework should say so explicitly. Otherwise, people may assume designation itself authorizes all three."

Selene spoke next.

"Northmark supports a graduated approach. Reporting requirements are not the same as reserving capacity. If the Authority wants a business to hold production capacity available for emergencies, that capacity has a commercial cost. The arrangement should identify who pays it."

Halden turned toward her.

"What if the region cannot afford to reserve capacity from every supplier it might need?"

"Then it must prioritize which capacity is worth paying to secure," Selene replied. "That is a budget decision, not a reason to pretend reserved capacity is free."

Harlan nodded vigorously.

Aria almost smiled.

For once, somebody had managed to make the economics obvious without requiring a twelve-page report.

The working group agreed to develop separate provisions for reporting, continuity planning, and compulsory emergency orders. The details remained unsettled, but the distinction would no longer be treated as a minor drafting issue.

Then the chair introduced a new proposal.

Under certain conditions, the Authority could require a designated community to maintain a minimum level of essential production during an emergency, even when the community had not entered a voluntary supply agreement.

The proposal included compensation, written orders, and a review procedure.

It did not yet define the minimum level, the duration of the obligation, or the circumstances in which existing contracts could be displaced.

Aria read the draft.

Then she looked up.

"This is the part we need to discuss."

Halden folded his hands.

"We knew you would say that."

"Good. Then we can save time."

A few people laughed.

Aria pointed to the phrase minimum level of essential production.

"Who defines essential production?"

"The relevant department, based on regional need."

"Who verifies that the materials are available?"

"The department would consult the registry."

"The registry distinguishes available surplus from existing commitments. If the available surplus is insufficient, what happens?"

"The order may need to account for the shortage."

"May need to? Or must?"

The representative from Continuity Planning consulted his notes.

"That has not been finalized."

Aria moved to the next line.

"How long can the obligation continue?"

"Until the emergency conditions have sufficiently improved."

"Who determines that?"

"The Authority."

"Which department?"

"That depends on the emergency."

"And if the department issuing the order is not the department responsible for reviewing the emergency?"

The representative paused.

"That would require coordination."

Aria put down the document.

"Then we have identified the problem. The proposal describes what the Authority may require, but it doesn’t yet define how the requirement begins, how it is measured, or how it ends."

Halden’s expression hardened.

"Ms. Aria, we cannot write a separate law for every possible emergency."

"No. But we can write rules that prevent an emergency order from becoming an indefinite obligation."

Cassian, seated near the end of the table, spoke for the first time.

"I suggest we add a defined review interval, with written reasons required for renewal. We should also distinguish the initial order from any extension."

Elira nodded.

"And the order should identify the quantity, payment method, duration, and known conflicts with existing contracts."

Selene added another point.

"If reserved capacity is required beyond the immediate emergency, the Authority should explain why a voluntary reservation agreement is insufficient."

Halden looked around the table.

The proposal was no longer being debated as a simple choice between preparedness and freedom. It had become a discussion about evidence, cost, procedure, and the limits of administrative discretion.

That was harder.

It was also more useful.

"Very well," Halden said. "The drafting team will prepare revisions."

Aria recorded the decision.

She had not defeated compulsory continuity powers. Nobody had promised to remove them.

But the working group had accepted that those powers needed clearer boundaries.

For now, that was enough to continue.

As the meeting ended, Silas Veyr approached Aria.

She had expected him to leave with the other commercial representatives, but he carried a slim folder and appeared to have been waiting for a quieter moment.

"Your questions were precise," he said.

"I’ve had practice."

"So I noticed."

He placed the folder on the table between them.

"My consortium has prepared a proposal for regional continuity contracts. It may address some of the concerns raised today."

Aria did not open it immediately.

"What does the consortium want in return?"

"Reliable supply. Predictable prices. A framework that allows businesses to plan before an emergency begins."

"That sounds reasonable."

"It is intended to be."

"Then the terms should survive being read carefully."

A faint smile crossed his face.

"I would expect nothing less."

She opened the folder.

The proposal offered participating communities payment for reserving a defined percentage of production capacity. In exchange, the consortium would receive priority access to the reserved goods during specified regional emergencies.

It included fixed reservation fees, minimum purchase commitments, and compensation for cancellations.

At first glance, it was considerably better than the earlier proposals she had seen.

Then she reached the section concerning participation.

Businesses entering a continuity contract would be required to provide quarterly capacity reports, identify material suppliers, disclose major changes in production, and notify the consortium of new contracts that might affect reserved capacity.

Aria stopped.

"Why does the consortium need to know the identity of every major supplier?"

"To evaluate reliability."

"Could a supplier provide verified risk information without disclosing every commercial relationship?"

"Possibly."

"Could a business decline to disclose a customer contract that has no effect on the reserved capacity?"

"That would depend on the final wording."

She continued reading.

The proposal also allowed the consortium to request additional capacity during a regional emergency, subject to availability and a separate payment arrangement.

Aria looked up.

"Who decides whether the requested capacity is available?"

"The supplier, under the proposed framework."

"And if the supplier and consortium disagree?"

"The contract would provide a dispute process."

"Before or after delivery is due?"

Silas took a breath.

"You are determined to find every weakness."

"I’m determined to find the weaknesses before someone builds a business around them."

He nodded toward the document.

"Then you may be interested in helping shape the proposal. The consortium intends to submit it to the Authority."

"Who would control the registry of participating businesses?"

"The consortium would maintain its commercial records. The Authority would retain its own registry."

"Would the consortium be allowed to share those records with the Authority?"

"Under defined circumstances."

"Defined by whom?"

"By the agreement and applicable law."

Aria closed the folder.

"Then those definitions need to exist before anyone signs."

Silas studied her.

"You understand that refusing every arrangement creates its own risks."

"I don’t intend to refuse every arrangement."

"You have declined investment, rejected exclusive distribution, and resisted designation."

"I declined to sell control of New Beginning. I accepted a distribution agreement without exclusivity. I signed a storage agreement with the Authority. And I’m willing to discuss continuity contracts."

She pushed the folder back toward him.

"What I resist is an arrangement that gives someone else more certainty than it gives the people expected to provide it."

For a moment, Silas said nothing.

Then he picked up the folder.

"That is a useful distinction."

"It’s an expensive one if you ignore it."

"Indeed."

He turned to leave, then paused.

"One question, Aria. If the Authority eventually designates New Beginning and imposes a lawful minimum production requirement, will you refuse?"

Aria considered her answer.

"I would examine the order. If the requirement were justified, achievable, properly compensated, and limited to the circumstances that justified it, I would have to consider it seriously."

"And if it weren’t?"

"Then I would challenge it."

Silas nodded slowly.

"Most people would answer that question with a simple yes or no."

"Most people are usually being asked the wrong question."

He left without another word.

Kelme appeared beside her a moment later.

"Was that a threat?"

"No."

"An offer?"

"Possibly."

"Should I be worried?"

Aria glanced toward the door through which Silas had disappeared.

"Yes."

Kelme sighed.

"I preferred it when you said no."

That night, Aria returned to the council building alone.

She laid the continuity proposal beside the Authority’s assessment notice and the certified extracts from the emergency regulations.

Three documents.

Three different approaches to the same problem.

The Authority wanted to secure essential supply.

The consortium wanted predictable access to goods.

New Beginning wanted to remain independent while still cooperating with the region.

None of those goals was inherently unreasonable.

The danger lay in allowing one party’s need for certainty to become another party’s unlimited obligation.

Aria opened her notebook and began drafting the settlement’s formal response.

She would not argue that New Beginning should be exempt from every emergency measure. That position would be difficult to defend, and it would not help the region prepare for real shortages.

Instead, she would ask for clear designation criteria, evidence-based capacity assessments, written orders, payment terms, review deadlines, and defined conditions for ending compulsory obligations.

She would offer a voluntary continuity plan with specified limits.

She would also insist that the Authority develop alternative supply routes and support additional suppliers, rather than treating New Beginning’s success as a permanent solution to the region’s weaknesses.

Her pen moved steadily.

Then a knock sounded at the door.

Martha entered carrying a sealed envelope.

"This arrived from the regional office. They said it requires the council’s attention."

Aria broke the seal.

Inside was a preliminary classification report.

The report did not designate New Beginning yet.

It recommended that the Authority consider doing so.

The stated reasons were its location, its expanding commercial activity, the number of businesses using its road access, and its growing role in regional supply.

Those were facts Aria could verify.

But the final section contained a new concern.

Risk of operational disruption caused by independent decision-making.

Aria read the phrase once.

Then again.

Martha leaned over her shoulder.

"What does that mean?"

Aria felt the familiar tightening in her chest—not fear exactly, but the recognition that a discussion had shifted into more dangerous territory.

"I’m not sure."

"Could they mean that we might refuse an emergency order?"

"Possibly."

"Wouldn’t that be true of any independent business?"

"Yes."

Martha looked at the report.

"Then why single us out?"

Aria checked the document’s reference number.

The report cited the settlement’s previous refusal of exclusive investment, its decision to maintain independent distribution, and its insistence on council approval for major commitments.

The same choices that had protected New Beginning from dependence were now being listed as potential risks to regional continuity.

Aria placed the report on the table.

"They’re asking whether our independence makes us unreliable."

"Are we?"

"No."

She paused.

"But we are independent. That means we can make decisions the Authority doesn’t like."

Martha sat down.

"Can we prove that independence makes us more reliable, not less?"

Aria looked at the other documents.

The supplier records. The signed storage agreement. The verified production figures. The council’s contracts. The emergency allocation history.

Perhaps they could.

They could show that New Beginning had honored its commitments, corrected its own mistakes, and cooperated when the terms were clear. They could demonstrate that independence had not prevented responsibility.

But they could not prove that they would always agree with the Authority.

And that, Aria suspected, was the real issue.

She took a fresh sheet of paper.

At the top, she wrote:

Reliability Is Not Obedience.

Then she began listing every instance in which New Beginning had cooperated voluntarily—and every safeguard that had made that cooperation possible.

Because the next meeting would not simply ask whether New Beginning was important enough to protect.

It would ask whether the settlement could be trusted to remain independent.

And for the first time, Aria understood that the Authority might consider those two things incompatible.

She intended to prove otherwise.

If you find any errors (non-standard content, ads redirect, broken links, etc..), Please let us know so we can fix it as soon as possible.

Report

Use arrow keys (or A / D) to PREV/NEXT chapter