Indian Horror System: Urban Legends of India
Chapter 29: Different burger, same cheese
"There was a time when these streets were full of life. Merchants filled the marketplaces, temples drew worshippers, and grand havelis stood where you now see crumbling walls. Bhangarh was once a prosperous settlement." The guide’s explanation accompanied their walk through the deserted marketplace.
El slowed beside a crumbling shopfront, lifting his phone to capture the stone archway beyond it.
He took another picture, adjusting the angle to include the hills beyond the ruins.
The place was considerably more extensive than he had expected. The abandoned streets, scattered temples, and roofless buildings gave him some idea of how much life the settlement must once have contained.
It was difficult to imagine merchants calling out to customers in the very streets they were walking through now.
"What happened to it?" Rin asked, running her fingers along the rough stone wall, its surface chipped and cracked from centuries of weathering.
"The legends offer their own explanations," the guide replied.
"A holy man named Baba Balau Nath lived here long before the fort was built. He agreed to let the settlement grow on one condition: no building could cast its shadow upon his dwelling."
Ryan, who had been looking at a row of ruined houses, turned toward them. "Why would something like that matter to him?"
"Maybe it wasn’t the shadow itself that mattered," Rin said, reminding him that it was a legend.
The guide smiled at their exchange.
"The condition was respected for years, or so the story goes.
Later, Ajab Singh, a descendant of the original ruler, is said to have raised the palace. Its shadow reached the holy man’s dwelling, breaking the condition.
Baba Balau Nath had warned that such a violation would bring destruction upon the settlement, and the legend says he cursed Bhangarh."
El glanced toward the ruins stretching ahead, considering the tale while taking another photograph.
A long section of wall framed the distant palace, and he moved a few steps to the side to capture it.
"So the ruler ignored the warning, and the town paid the price. Though, judging by these ruins, the place hardly needs a curse to make an impression," he remarked.
"That’s what the legend says. Whether it explains the town’s decline is another matter," the guide answered.
"Fair enough."
Rin glanced at El as he resumed photographing the old marketplace. "At this rate, you’ll have a picture of every building before we leave."
"I’m simply appreciating the architecture," he replied, prompting her to shake her head before walking ahead with Ryan.
El was about to follow when a detail in the guide’s explanation caught his attention. "Wait, isn’t there another legend about Princess Ratnavati and a tantric?" (A/N: Tantric— Sorcerer, mostly associated with black magic and forbidden rituals)
The guide nodded. "Yes, that’s the other famous tale. My grandfather used to say that breaking Baba Balau Nath’s condition brought misfortune upon the ruler and his descendants. The story of Princess Ratnavati tells of another curse, though some people believe the two are connected."
El put his phone away to listen.
"A tantric named Singhiya supposedly fell in love with Rajkumari Ratnavati and attempted to win her through magic. He enchanted an oil intended for the princess, hoping to ensnare her affection. She uncovered his scheme and foiled it, and the tale says he cursed the settlement before his death."
"Different burger, same cheese," El remarked, finding the similarity between the two legends hard to ignore.
"That’s why you’ll hear both stories here. Some people believe the curses are connected; others consider them separate legends. Either way, they’ve become inseparable from Bhangarh’s reputation."
El looked toward the royal complex, where the remains of the palace rose above the surrounding buildings. "One is about a broken promise, the other about obsession. Either way, things went rather badly for the town."
"Perhaps that’s why people still tell them," the guide said. "They give people something to remember about a place that might otherwise be known only for its ruins."
El considered that as he raised his phone again. Whatever the truth behind Bhangarh’s decline, the settlement made for some striking photographs.
He captured the carved entrance of a temple, then turned toward Rin and Ryan, who had stopped beside a weathered archway.
Rin noticed him looking and beckoned him over. "El, come take a picture."
"Sure." He joined her beside the arch, where the afternoon light fell across the old stonework.
"You’re supposed to be in it too. Come on," she added, adjusting her position until they both fitted comfortably into the frame.
El raised his phone, checked the composition, and waited for her to settle into a smile.
"Got it. Ready?"
Just as he pressed the shutter, Ryan jumped between them, thrusting up a victory sign with a grin that threatened to swallow his entire face.
Click!
El lowered the phone and examined the result.
Ryan occupied the centre of the photograph, his face far too close to the camera. Rin had turned toward him in surprise, while El looked caught halfway between a smile and an expression of disbelief.
Rin stared at him. "Ryan! You couldn’t wait until we’d taken the picture?"
"Ah, sorry~! I didn’t mean to jump into the picture."
’Kekeke... You actually thought I’d let you take a picture with my sister that easily, you invader?’ Ryan’s grin widened as he admired his handiwork.
Rin was still nagging him about ruining their picture, but Ryan had already decided the result was worth it.
His sister could complain all she wanted.
The important thing was that the photograph had been taken, and El’s attempt at getting a picture with her had been thoroughly sabotaged.
El enlarged the photograph, examining the disastrous composition.
Ryan’s face dominated one side of the frame, Rin looked caught halfway between surprise and annoyance, and El himself was no better.
"Hey, come take a look at this." El tilted the phone toward Rin, showing her the picture.
Rin stopped the nagging as she leaned closer to examine the picture, bringing her shoulder almost against his as she studied Ryan’s enormous face in the foreground.
El pointed out how perfectly he’d managed to ruin the framing, while Rin insisted that the boy had clearly planned the whole thing.
Their attempts to defend their respective positions only made the photograph funnier, and before long, Rin was laughing too hard to maintain her earlier annoyance.
She lightly nudged El’s arm as she giggled, and he tilted the phone toward her again, letting her inspect the picture properly.
Ryan’s smile gradually faded.
His mouth hung open as he watched the two of them laughing together over the very photograph he’d sabotaged.
He had expected Rin to keep scolding him and El to be annoyed, not for the two of them to turn his carefully planned interference into their own little moment.
’Wait... This isn’t how it was supposed to go!’
He stared at them in disbelief, his triumphant expression crumbling as Rin asked El to send her the picture.
El did so without hesitation, and she saved it with a grin, apparently deciding that the ridiculous result was worth keeping.
Ryan could only watch as his sister thanked El and began suggesting they take a few more pictures at a better spot.
That got her moving again.
Rin glanced around the ruins, searching for a backdrop she liked, then beckoned the others to follow. Ryan hurried after her, still looking mildly betrayed by the outcome of his own scheme.
When he turned back, Rosie was hovering beside him.
Her gaze lingered on the direction Rin had gone before settling on El, and the slight downturn of her lips gave away more than she probably intended.
El studied her face. "You wanted a picture too?"
"I didn’t say that."
"You didn’t need to."
Rosie looked away, folding her arms. "You seemed rather happy taking pictures with her."
"Ryan was there too."
"Hmgh!" Rosie pouted, turning away with a hint of jealousy.
El understood. Rosie rarely admitted when something bothered her, preferring to hide it rather than acknowledge her jealousy.
He stepped a little aside from the others and took out his phone. "Come here. Let’s take one together."
Rosie turned toward him, the guarded expression on her face easing as she drifted closer.
El stood beside her, angling the camera so the old archway and the sunlit ruins appeared behind him. He raised one hand and formed half a heart with his fingers, leaving the other half open for her to complete.
Rosie looked at the gesture, then at him. A small smile appeared on her face as she lifted her own hand to match his.
"Say cheese~!"
"But I don’t like cheese, hubby~"
Click!
He checked the screen.
The photograph showed El standing alone, his fingers forming half a heart beside an empty space.
The composition was otherwise lovely, with the weathered arch and warm stonework behind him, but the absence beside his hand was impossible to overlook.
Rosie’s hand lowered. She had known what would happen, yet seeing the result seemed to hurt more than she had expected.
The disappointment was brief, almost imperceptible, but El noticed it before she turned away.
"It’s okay," she said with a bittersweet smile. "The picture looks nice."
She drifted toward a nearby wall, where she began examining its carvings as though they had suddenly caught her attention.
El saved the photograph without another word.
There was no clever remark that could change what the camera had failed to capture, and he didn’t want to make light of something that clearly mattered to her.
The group continued exploring the ruins, passing a temple whose carved stonework had survived remarkably well and another stretch of abandoned buildings where trees had grown through broken walls.
Ryan kept asking the guide questions, sometimes about the legends and sometimes about the architecture, while Rin tried to keep him from wandering too far ahead.
El took a few more photographs, but Rosie grew quieter whenever he reached for his phone. She stayed close to him, answering when he spoke, yet she no longer tried to join the pictures.
He noticed the change and let it be, though he found himself looking at her more often than the scenery.
By the time they had finished exploring, the sun had begun sinking behind the hills.
The golden light softened the ruins, catching the edges of the old walls and casting long shadows across the path.
"We should start heading back," the guide said, checking the time. "I’ve arranged a camp nearby, and the staff should have everything prepared by the time we arrive."
Ryan immediately turned toward him. "Does that mean dinner will be ready?"
"Yes, young sir."
"Then let’s go!"
Rin laughed as Ryan hurried ahead, already asking what they would be eating. The guide followed at an easy pace, leading them along the path toward the camp.
El and Rosie remained a little behind the others.
He took out his phone and looked through the photographs from the day, passing the ruined archways, the temple carvings, and the picture Ryan had so enthusiastically ruined.
He stopped at the photograph he had taken with Rosie, his thumb resting against the edge of the screen.
Rosie noticed. "You’re keeping that one?"
"Of course."
"But why? It’s not good, after all..." Her voice started out high, then gradually sank into a little whisper.
El looked at her. "Do you know why people take so many pictures?"
"To remember things."
"Partly. There’s an idea that photographs help preserve memories, but they only capture a small piece of an experience. They can’t keep everything that happened around that moment, and they can’t guarantee we’ll remember how it felt years later.
You might look at a picture and remember where you were, but forget the conversation that happened just before it. You might remember someone’s face without remembering what made you laugh together."
Rosie listened quietly as they walked. The others were far enough ahead that their conversation remained private, and the evening breeze carried the last warmth of the day across the path.
"Then what’s the point of taking pictures?" she asked.
"They’re worth keeping. I’m glad I took them today." El slipped his phone into his pocket.
"But a photograph isn’t the whole memory. Sometimes the smallest parts of a day are the ones that stay with you, even when there’s nothing to look at to bring them back."
He turned his gaze toward the setting sun. Its fading light spread across the hills, leaving the ruins behind them in muted gold and shadow.
Rosie lowered her eyes. "But you won’t forget the pictures, will you?"
"I might forget where I saved them," El replied, earning a faint smile from her. "I’m not saying photographs are useless. I’m saying they don’t have to contain everything for the moment to matter."
He looked at her then, his expression gentle.
"It just means the memories I make with you will last longer than those pictures."
Rosie looked up at him. The sadness hadn’t vanished entirely, but her expression softened, and she moved closer until her shoulder rested against his arm.
"You’d better remember that," she murmured.
"I will."
El walked beside Rosie beneath the fading sky, content to leave the camera in his pocket.
The day had given him plenty of photographs, but the moment he wanted to keep was the one that would never appear in any of them.
A/N: Three power stones a day keep the Chapters from wandering away.
If you find any errors (non-standard content, ads redirect, broken links, etc..), Please let us know so we can fix it as soon as possible.
ReportUse arrow keys (or A / D) to PREV/NEXT chapter
Loading comments…