Chapter 75: The Provincial Judge

Chapter 75: Chapter 75: The Provincial Judge

POV: Nikolai Petrovich Sokolov

Vyshny Volochyok, Tver Province. Judicial District.

The snow of Vyshny Volochyok was not much different from the snow of any other place in the Empire. It fell with the same gray insistence, covered the same tin roofs and the same irregular cobblestones, piled up in the same corners where the wind stacked it against the walls. What set Vyshny Volochyok apart from other places was the water. The canals that cut through the city, vestiges of the navigation system that had connected the Volga to the Baltic since the time of Peter the Great, froze in winter into flat white surfaces that children used for skating and drunks for falling down. In summer, those same canals carried barges loaded with grain and timber. In February, they carried nothing...

Judge Nikolai Petrovich Sokolov hated the silence of winter. He found it oppressive, as if the entire city were waiting for something that never quite arrived. He preferred the noise of carts, the shouts of vendors, the hammering in the workshops. He preferred life. But life in February was reduced to the interiors of houses and taverns, and Judge Sokolov, at fifty-three, had developed a complicated relationship with interiors.

His office in the district court building was small and cold. The walls were covered with shelves of legal codes no one consulted, and the desk was a solid piece of oak that had belonged to his predecessor and to his predecessor’s predecessor. On the desk were three folders. The three folders were the problem.

The first folder contained a complaint. It had been filed by Vera Ivanovna Morozova, teacher at the parish school of the village of Zarechye, twelve versts from the city. The complaint was detailed, meticulous, truly obsessive in appearance.

Over the past six months, Teacher Morozova had documented the presence of children under fourteen in the textile factory owned by Count Alexei Bobrinsky. She had noted their names, their ages, the hours they worked, the conditions in which they worked. She had interviewed the parents, taken notes, gathered testimonies. The complaint was twenty-three pages long and had an appendix with the names of forty-seven children.

The second folder contained a letter. It had been sent by Prince Gagarin, marshal of the nobility of the district, two days after the complaint was filed. The letter was brief and courteous. Prince Gagarin expressed his confidence that Judge Sokolov would know how to evaluate the complaint with the prudence it required. He reminded the judge that Count Bobrinsky’s factory employed more than two hundred workers, that it sustained the economy of three villages, that it paid its taxes punctually. He also reminded him that Teacher Morozova had a reputation as an agitator, that she had been seen in the company of students from the University of Moscow, that her pedagogical methods were innovative in the worst sense of the word. The letter asked for nothing explicitly. It did not need to.

The third folder contained a telegram. It had arrived that very morning from St. Petersburg, bearing the seal of the Ministry of Justice. The telegram informed Judge Sokolov that the Bobrinsky factory case had been assigned to an inspector from the Imperial Security Directorate, who would arrive in Vyshny Volochyok in the coming days to supervise the proceedings. The telegram asked for nothing explicitly. It did not need to either.

Judge Sokolov looked at the three folders. Then he looked out the window. The snow kept falling. The canal remained frozen. The silence remained oppressive.

He sighed.

Nikolai Petrovich Sokolov had been born in Torzhok, sixty versts from Vyshny Volochyok, into a family of judicial officials. His father had been a clerk in the Torzhok court. His grandfather had been a clerk in the Torzhok court. The judicial career was not a vocation in his family. It was an inheritance. A tradition. A way of earning a living without having to dirty one’s hands with manual labor.

The young Nikolai had studied law at the University of St. Petersburg, graduated with mediocre grades, and returned to the province to take the post his father had secured for him. He had risen slowly, on the strength of years of service and a natural talent for staying out of trouble. He had been an examining magistrate for fifteen years. He had been a district judge for twelve. He had watched governments, ministers, reforms pass by. He had learned that survival in the Russian judicial system required three things: patience, discretion, and the ability to distinguish between the problems one can solve and the problems one must dodge.

The Bobrinsky factory case was a problem that could not be dodged.

He had known it from the moment Vera Ivanovna Morozova had entered his office with the complaint under her arm. The teacher was a woman of about thirty-five, with her hair pulled back in a severe bun and gray eyes that did not blink when they lied. She wore simple clothes, of good quality but without adornment. She spoke with a precision that was uncomfortable, as if every word were calibrated to leave no gaps. Judge Sokolov had listened to her for forty minutes. He had not interrupted. He had not asked questions. He had only taken notes.

When the teacher finished, Judge Sokolov had told her the complaint would be evaluated. That the procedure would follow its course. That she would be informed of any development. The teacher had nodded, gathered her papers, and left without adding anything more.

Judge Sokolov had waited three days before opening the folder. Three days during which he had tried to convince himself that the case was not so serious. That the complaint was exaggerated. That Teacher Morozova was an agitator. That Count Bobrinsky was a respectable man. That the best thing for everyone was to file the matter away without further ado.

He had not succeeded.

The problem was not the complaint itself. The problem was the law. the Minors Protection Act, signed by the Tsar three weeks earlier, explicitly prohibited the employment of children under fourteen in dangerous industries. Count Bobrinsky’s textile factory was a dangerous industry under the law’s definition. The forty-seven children documented by Teacher Morozova were under fourteen. The law was clear. The case was clear.

But Count Bobrinsky was a nobleman. A nobleman with connections. A nobleman who had served as civil governor of the province before retiring to his lands. A nobleman who knew Prince Gagarin, the Governor, the Bishop personally. A nobleman who could make life impossible for a district judge.

Judge Sokolov had seen what happened to officials who stood up to noblemen. He had seen a prosecutor from Tver transferred to a clerk’s post in Arkhangelsk for having dared to investigate a landowner. He had seen an examining magistrate dismissed for having ruled against a friend of the Governor. He had seen a court secretary imprisoned for having leaked information about a corruption case involving a member of the State Council.

The system was designed to protect the powerful. Judge Sokolov had known that since he was a child. His father had taught it to him. His grandfather had taught it to him. It was a lesson passed down from generation to generation, like a family secret, like a formula for survival.

But the system was also changing. The law was new. The Tsar had signed it. The ISD was sending inspectors. Someone in St. Petersburg was paying attention.

Judge Sokolov did not know what to do.

Prince Gagarin’s visit was the second act of the same drama.

The Prince arrived at eleven in the morning, with a punctuality Judge Sokolov did not expect from a man of his rank. He was a tall man, about sixty, with white hair and a precisely trimmed beard. He wore a bearskin coat that must have cost more than the judge’s annual salary. He entered the office without knocking, without announcing himself, with the assurance of a man who knows his presence is always welcome.

"Judge Sokolov", said the Prince, extending a gloved hand. "I regret not having been able to visit you sooner. The roads are impassable this time of year".

Judge Sokolov shook the hand. The Prince’s grip was firm, brief, calculated. "Prince Gagarin. It is an honor".

"The honor is mine". The Prince took a seat in the visitor’s chair, the only one in the office. "I have come to discuss a matter that concerns me. A matter that I know also concerns you".

Judge Sokolov did not answer. He waited.

Prince Gagarin took a silver cigarette case from his coat pocket, offered a cigarette to the judge, and when he declined, lit one for himself. The smoke rose in slow spirals toward the ceiling. "Teacher Morozova’s complaint", said the Prince, as if the name were distasteful to him. "I have read the document. It is detailed. It is meticulous. It is the work of a person who knows what she is doing".

"The complaint is filed", replied Judge Sokolov. "It will follow the appropriate course".

"Of course. Of course". The Prince exhaled smoke. "No one disputes that. The law is the law. And the law says cases must be investigated. No one wants to obstruct justice. But it also says cases must be evaluated with judgment. With prudence. With common sense". He paused. "Count Bobrinsky is a respectable man. A man who has served the Empire for decades. A man who employs two hundred workers. A man who pays his taxes. A man who contributes to the prosperity of this province".

Judge Sokolov knew what was coming next. He had heard it a hundred times before. "His factory employs children", he said. It was not a question. It was a statement.

Prince Gagarin did not flinch. "His factory employs young people. Apprentices. Boys who need to work to support their families. Boys whose parents have no other choice. If Count Bobrinsky did not give them work, they would starve. The law says children must not work. But the law also says children must not starve. Sometimes the two things are incompatible".

Judge Sokolov looked at the three folders on his desk. The complaint. The letter. The telegram. Three documents representing three different powers. The power of the law. The power of the nobility. The power of the Tsar. And he, a provincial judge, at the center of all three.

"I understand your concern, Prince", said Judge Sokolov, choosing his words carefully. "But the law is clear. If the complaint has merit, the case must proceed".

Prince Gagarin stubbed out his cigarette in a bronze ashtray. "No one is saying it should not proceed. I am only saying that Count Bobrinsky has friends. Friends at court. Friends in the State Council. Friends who might interpret a conviction as an attack on the nobility as a whole". He stood up. "And you, Judge Sokolov, have a family. A wife. Two children. A son in the army. A daughter who wants to marry". He paused. "It would be a shame if an error of judgment were to affect them".

Judge Sokolov did not answer. He did not need to.

Prince Gagarin adjusted his coat. "Think about it, Judge. Think about what is at stake. Not only for Count Bobrinsky, but for all of us". He walked toward the door. Before leaving, he turned. "The law is the law. But justice is something else. And sometimes justice consists of knowing when not to apply it".

He left without waiting for an answer.

Judge Sokolov remained alone in his office. The snow kept falling. The canal remained frozen. The silence remained oppressive.

He looked at the three folders. Then he looked out the window. Then, with a slow movement, he opened the bottom drawer of his desk. Inside was a bottle of vodka. He took it out. He set it on the table. He did not open it. He only looked at it.

The ISD inspector arrived the next day.

His name was Dmitri Alexandrovich Volkov. He was twenty-eight, dark hair cut in military fashion, and light eyes that moved no more than necessary. He wore a plain-cut gray coat, no insignia, no decorations. His only identification was a metal badge he showed on entering, which read, simply, IMPERIAL SECURITY DIRECTORATE.

Judge Sokolov received him in his office. He offered him tea. Inspector Volkov accepted without smiling. He sat in the same chair Prince Gagarin had occupied the day before. He placed a folder on the table. He opened it.

"The Bobrinsky factory case", said Inspector Volkov, without preamble. "Vera Ivanovna Morozova’s complaint. Forty-seven children. Twenty-three pages. An appendix with names and ages".

"The complaint is filed", replied Judge Sokolov, repeating the phrase he had used with the Prince. "The procedure is following its course".

"The procedure is following its course", repeated Inspector Volkov, as if the phrase struck him as insufficient. "I have reviewed the file. The complaint was filed eleven days ago. Since then, no statement has been taken. No witness has been summoned. The factory has not been inspected. Nothing has been done".

Judge Sokolov felt sweat beading on his forehead. "Judicial procedures require time. The investigation must be meticulous. One cannot accuse a man without evidence".

"The evidence is in the complaint", said Inspector Volkov, and his voice was cold and sharp as the edge of a knife. "Teacher Morozova has documented every case. She has interviewed every family. She has gathered testimonies. What is missing is not evidence. What is missing is will".

Judge Sokolov did not answer.

Inspector Volkov closed the folder. "Judge Sokolov, I will be direct with you. The Imperial Security Directorate is not here to supervise routine procedures. We are here because the Tsar has signed a law and that law must be applied. Not in St. Petersburg. Not in Moscow. Here. In Vyshny Volochyok. In every judicial district of the Empire. And if the district judges do not apply the law, the Directorate has the authority to intervene".

"Intervene how?" asked Judge Sokolov, and his voice sounded more defiant than he intended.

Inspector Volkov looked at him without blinking. "Intervene as necessary. Arrest those responsible. Shut down the factory. Prosecute the accomplices. Starting with the owner. And continuing with all those who have facilitated the commission of the crime. Including local authorities. Including judicial officials who have obstructed the investigation".

Judge Sokolov felt the ground shift beneath his feet. "Are you threatening me?"

"I am informing you of the consequences of inaction. The decision is yours". Inspector Volkov stood up. "You have forty-eight hours to make a determination. If in forty-eight hours you have not initiated the formal investigation, the Directorate will initiate it for you. And the consequences will be whatever they may be".

He walked toward the door. Before leaving, he turned.

"One more thing, Judge. Count Bobrinsky has powerful friends. That is true. But it is also true that the Tsar has more powerful friends. And the Tsar has signed this law. Think about it".

He left without waiting for an answer.

Judge Sokolov remained alone. The bottle of vodka was still on the table. He looked at it. Then he looked at the three folders. The complaint. The letter. The telegram.

He opened the top drawer of his desk. He took out a sheet of paper. He took out a pen. He took out a bottle of ink. And he began to write.

He wrote for two hours. He wrote a formal investigation order. He wrote a summons for Count Bobrinsky. He wrote an inspection request for the Zarechye textile factory. He wrote a notification for Prince Gagarin, informing him that the case was proceeding according to law. He wrote a letter to the Ministry of Justice, requesting instructions on how to proceed in the event of resistance from local authorities.

When he finished, he signed each document with his full name. Nikolai Petrovich Sokolov. District Judge of Vyshny Volochyok. The letters trembled slightly on the paper, but they were legible. They were firm.

He called his secretary. A young man of twenty, thin and nervous, who had been in the post six months and had not yet learned not to be surprised by anything. "Vasili", said Judge Sokolov. "Take these documents to the registry. Have them stamped. Have them served. Today".

The secretary took the papers with trembling hands. He read the first. He read the second. His eyes widened. "A summons for Count Bobrinsky, sir?"

"Yes".

"And a notification for Prince Gagarin?"

"Yes".

The secretary swallowed. "Are you sure, sir?"

Judge Sokolov looked at him. For the first time in two days, he felt something like calm. It was not the calm of a man who has solved his problems. It was the calm of a man who has decided to stop dodging them.

"No", he said. "I am not sure of anything. But the law is the law. And I am a judge. It is the only thing I know how to do".

The secretary nodded. He took the documents. He left the office.

Judge Sokolov remained alone. He looked out the window. The snow kept falling. The canal remained frozen. The silence remained oppressive.

But for the first time in a long while, Judge Nikolai Petrovich Sokolov did not find it unbearable.

He took the bottle of vodka. He put it back in the drawer. He did not need it.

That night, when he arrived home, his wife asked him what had happened. He told her nothing. That it was a routine case. That she should not worry. She looked at him with that expression the wives of judicial officials learn to use when they know their husbands are lying to them. She did not insist.

Judge Sokolov dined with his family. Cabbage soup. Rye bread. A piece of herring. He ate in silence. His children talked about trivial things. School. Friends. The cold. He listened without listening. His mind was elsewhere.

After dinner, when the children had gone to bed and his wife remained mending a shirt by the stove, Judge Sokolov sat facing the window. He looked at the street. The snow kept falling. A cart passed, wheels creaking on the ice. A dog barked in the distance. A light went out in a neighboring house.

He thought of Prince Gagarin. Of his bearskin coat. Of his silver cigarette case. Of his veiled threats. He thought of Inspector Volkov. Of his folder. Of his badge. Of his cold eyes. He thought of Teacher Morozova. Of her complaint. Of her twenty-three pages. Of her forty-seven children. He thought of the Tsar. Of his law. Of his signature. Of his power. He thought of the Tsarevich. Of the boy who had read more science books than theology. Of the boy who had expelled Rasputin. Of the boy who was building a new Empire on the foundations of the old.

He thought of himself. Of his fifty-three years. Of his mediocre career. Of his family. Of his debts. Of his fears.

And then he thought of one more thing. One thing he had not thought of before. One thing that surprised him to discover.

He thought that, for the first time in a long while, he felt proud of himself.

It was not a loud pride. It was not a pride that shouted. It was a small, quiet pride, settling in his chest like a gentle warmth. It was the pride of having done the right thing. Of having signed the documents. Of having made the decision.

He did not know what was going to happen. He did not know if Count Bobrinsky would be convicted. He did not know if Prince Gagarin would carry out his threats. He did not know if he would lose his post. He did not know if his family would suffer. He did not know if, in a few months, he would be in a Siberian village, counting sheep and souls, as happened to officials who stood up to the powerful.

But he knew he had done the right thing.

And that, for now, was enough.

He rose from the chair. He walked to the stove. He sat beside his wife. She looked up from the shirt she was mending.

"Are you all right?" she asked.

"Yes", said Judge Sokolov. "I am all right".

She looked at him for a moment. Then she returned to her sewing. He remained there, beside her, watching the fire as it devoured the loads of wood piled up. And so the two of them went to bed.

[Nemryz: If you’ve enjoyed this story and want to read ahead, I have more Chapters available on my patreon.com/Nemryz. Your support helps me continue writing this novel and AU. Thank you for reading! I invite you to subscribe to Patreon for free]