Chapter 461

“Hyaaaah!!!”

It was an incredibly loud scream.

Loud enough to make my ears ring. Hiyori's vocal cords were no joke.

Was the unfamiliar sensation entering her body really that shocking and terrifying?

I wasn't a woman, so I couldn't know for sure, but judging by the situation right before penetration, she had every right to scream.

Still, out of all the heroines, her reaction was definitely the most extreme.

I had barely pushed in at all, yet she was already like this... It made me both curious and a little worried about how she would react if I went any deeper.

I paused my movements and looked down at Hiyori. She had her arms plastered to her ribs, her hands curled into tight fists.

Her trembling arms seemed to reflect exactly how she was feeling. I needed to calm her down a bit.

“Hey.”

At my gentle tone, one of Hiyori's tightly squeezed eyes cracked open just a sliver.

She looked like she was forcing herself to peer at something gruesome, which made me feel a bit weird.

“You okay?”

Hiyori squeezed her eye shut again and asked back in a quivering voice.

“...What is it...? What's down there?”

“Does it hurt?”

“I don't know...! I'm asking you what that is...!”

I couldn't tell if she was asking even though she already knew, or if she genuinely had no idea.

Grip...

Right as I was struggling to figure out how to explain it to her, Hiyori grabbed the hem of my T-shirt and pulled it toward herself.

She wasn't trying to pull me in; she just needed something to hold onto for support.

“This feels weird... sunbae-nim, did you just put it inside me...?”

Hiyori looked up at me with teary eyes as she asked.

I gently stroked her cheek and nodded.

“Yeah.”

“No... no, no, no...!!”

Her mouth ran wild in pure disbelief, and a fierce glare lit up her eyes.

“Why would you just put it in without asking...! Did I say you could do that...?”

“Didn't you?”

“When did I ever...! You're so bad... Hk...”

Right in the middle of scolding me, Hiyori's mouth suddenly fell open.

Of all times, a sneeze was trying to force its way out.

Just as I suspected, her little nose twitched slightly before her head turned, nudging into the palm of my hand that was still cupping her cheek.

And...

“Achoo...!”

She let out a soft, cute sneeze.

At the same time, the muscles in her face and body tensed and then relaxed, and her hips involuntarily swallowed a little bit more of my cock.

With a wet slip, it slid about a third of the way inside her.

As it pushed deeper, I felt a faint popping sensation. It was likely the proof of the chastity Hiyori had guarded for so long.

“What...! What are you doing...! Why do you keep going deeper...!?”

Properly feeling that sensation entering her from the inside, Hiyori's flustered rambling sounded incredibly pitiful, yet adorable.

Plus, it was funny how she didn't even seem to care about losing her virginity and was entirely focused on getting her questions answered.

“I stopped. It didn't go any deeper.”

“I-is that so...?”

“Does it hurt?”

“Why do you keep asking me if it hurts...!”

“Because I'm worried about you. What kind of question is that?”

“Then why did you...”

She trailed off, clearly wanting to ask why I had pushed in deeper if I was so worried.

“You pulled it in. I didn't push it.”

“...When did I do that...! Stop lying to me...!”

“Well, I'm just glad you seem to be fine.”

“I'm not fine...! It hurts...! I feel like I'm dying...!”

She was being completely overdramatic.

If anyone was hurting right now, it was me, not Hiyori.

I was looming over her in an awkward, half-inserted posture, and since I was using one arm to support my weight while stroking her cheek with the other, my supporting arm was starting to ache.

“Really?”

“Really...! So do something about... Hk...!”

She cut herself off, taking a sharp gasp of air.

This time, she managed to stifle the sneeze. Then she grabbed my hand resting against her cheek and used it to swipe under her nose.

“What are you doing?”

“I thought my nose was running...”

“And why would you wipe it with my hand?”

“Because there aren't any tissues...”

Maybe the lingering sensation of the sneeze was still tickling her mouth and nose?

Her voice came out sounding incredibly pouty and cute.

I seriously couldn't tell if she was even aware of the thing sitting inside her.

Between swallowing me deeper because of a sneeze and randomly whining about her runny nose...

I had figured my first time with Hiyori would be somewhat unpredictable, but I hadn't expected it to bounce all over the place like this.

“There are tissues right here.”

“Where...?”

“On the nightstand next to the bed. Right under the lamp.”

“I don't see them...”

“How can you not know when you aren't even looking?”

“Whatever... Anyway, I don't think I like this.”

“Like what?”

“This.”

Hiyori pointed down at her lower stomach.

Was she trying to say my cock was small?

No, she probably meant that having it inside her just wasn't as arousing as what she had read or heard.

“You don't like it?”

“It just feels hard.”

“Where?”

“My lower stomach...”

“Your lower stomach feels hard?”

“Yeah...”

“It just feels hard? It doesn't hurt?”

“Not really...”

Hiyori's body, which had been so tense just moments before, was now completely relaxed.

Her nervousness seemed to have mostly melted away... The relief of not being in any pain must have been huge.

“Then should I push in a little more?”

“...It isn't already all the way in?”

“No.”

“Really...? Then just... push it in really slowly...”

Hiyori seemed to assume that the remaining length was very short.

Otherwise, there was no way she could be this okay with it.

Replying that I understood, I—

Squelch...!

So that Hiyori could fully feel it, I began to slide my cock in at an agonizingly slow pace, just as she requested.

Even as my hardened length slowly brushed past her vaginal walls, Hiyori didn't show much of a reaction, offering only a slight furrow of her brow.

But that calmness only lasted for a moment.

“Ah...!”

Once it passed the halfway mark, Hiyori's hips gave a sudden jerk.

“Is... is that all of it...?”

Her voice began to tremble again, as if she were finally registering the heavy sensation.

Pausing my advance, I gave my head a slight shake. Just as her eyes widened in realization, I pushed my hips forward again.

“Hic...!?”

Hiyori's pitch shot up dramatically as I sank in two-thirds of the way.

And when I pushed further, burying myself until only the base remained outside, “Ah...! Ah! Ah! Haaah!”

She unleashed a rapid string of sharp gasps, planting her hands into the bedsheets to prop up her upper body as she tried to scramble backward.

Her eyes were glued to where our bodies were joined.

“Th-this... feeling...”

Her lower half began to tense up once more.

“Hwaaa...!”

As I drove to the hilt, burying myself inside her, she lifted her pelvis off the bed and began to squirm. It seemed the sensation of having something buried so incredibly deep inside her had sparked a sudden rush of terror.

She seemed to be getting aroused too, but since her reactions so far had been so completely bizarre, I couldn't say for sure.

“I'm going to start moving a little bit. Tell me right away if it hurts.”

As I shifted into a comfortable position, ready to begin, Hiyori swallowed hard at my words.

Taking that as her consent, I pulled my hips slightly backward.

“Hnnng...!”

Accompanied by the adorable whimpers leaking from Hiyori's tightly bitten lips, I began a slow, rhythmic cycle of drawing back and driving forward.

The tightness squeezing my cock perfectly against her vaginal walls delivered intense waves of pleasure.

My mind started to haze over in bliss, and heavy, heated breaths escaped my nose.

Since our faces were close enough to brush against each other, Hiyori naturally felt my hot breath ghosting over her skin.

“Ah, what are you doing...!”

Perhaps thinking I was trying to mess with her, she grumbled a snappy complaint.

She even shook her head from side to side, burying her face into the pillow as she fussed.

She might have been trying to rub away the ticklish feeling of my breath, but that obviously wasn't her only reason.

Hiyori was undoubtedly getting turned on.

I could tell just by the involuntary reactions of her body, the tremors shaking her frame, and the tangled whimpers falling from her lips.

It was time to push a little harder.

Making up my mind, I began to slowly increase the pace and range of my thrusts.

I would slide almost all the way out with a wet drag, then drive deep back inside her.

“Hng...!”

Letting out a breathless sob, Hiyori arched her back tightly off the bed before sinking back down.

It seemed to be an involuntary reaction to pleasure that pushed past her very limits.

“M-Matsumatsu...! It hurts...! It hurts...!”

After a few more thrusts, her pitch skyrocketed again as she whined about the pain. I couldn't tell if it was real or if she was just being dramatic again.

“Does it really hurt?”

“Yes...!”

“Should I pull out for a second?”

“Yeah...! Take it out...! Let's take a break...! Just a little... it seriously hurts...”

“You don't seem like you're in pain.”

“I said it hurts...! Hic... You're so mean...”

It was obvious she was getting choked up from feeling wronged.

She really did seem to be in pain, so I figured I ought to give her a breather.

“Alright. I'm sorry.”

I quickly apologized, gently patted her waist, and slowly drew myself out of her.

At the same time, her hips rolled upward in a fluid, flexible motion.

Even just pulling out painted an incredibly hot picture. It made me question if I really needed to stop.

Suppressing that urge, I pulled away from Hiyori's crotch as she trembled like a leaf.

As if feeling finally liberated, Hiyori let out a deep sigh of relief, covered her chest with her arms, and sat up.

“Jeez...”

She glared daggers at me, looking seconds away from cussing me out, but then her expression slowly morphed into one of confusion.

Judging by the way she shifted her legs around, it seemed she'd felt something wet trickling near her calves.

Too embarrassed to look directly at my naked lower half, Hiyori kept her head turned, side-eying the sheets instead.

Her gaze eventually landed on a tiny, faint smear of bright red staining the sheets right below where we had been joined.

And... the moment Hiyori saw it, her eyes practically rolled back in her head.

“Wh-what is this...!! Blood!!!”