Hogwarts: This Hufflepuff Is a Menace!

Chapter 58: A Master at Turning the Tables—and Apparently Hermione Is His Enemy

  • Next Chapter

If they hadn’t still been in class, Hermione might have hit Black in the face with her textbook.

Sneaking off together was bad enough.

Now he was telling her about it?

What was that supposed to mean?

Was he trying to provoke her? Was he showing off?

Was she expected to congratulate them?

‘Hermione, do you really dislike Cassandra?’

She sniffed.

‘Can you tell me why?’

Another sniff.

‘People don’t usually hate someone for no reason.’

‘I don’t like her,’ Hermione whispered fiercely. ‘She’s arrogant. She acts as though everyone else is beneath her.’

Black listened.

‘Yes, she’s talented. So what? That doesn’t mean she gets to behave as though she’s better than everyone. And she never thinks about how the things she says make people feel.’

Black smiled.

‘What are you smiling at?’

Hermione could hardly believe him.

She was furious, and he was sitting there looking amused.

‘So those are the reasons you dislike her?’

‘Aren’t they enough? Don’t you think that’s horrible?’

Her Charms textbook was looking increasingly suitable for use as a weapon.

Black spoke without hurrying.

‘Does any of that sound familiar?’

‘What?’

‘Talented. Well read. Proud. Looks down on other people. Says things without considering how they’ll feel…’

With each point, Hermione’s face grew paler.

She had understood his question.

Familiar?

Yes.

Horribly familiar.

He might almost have been describing her.

She was talented. She knew a great deal. She had even learnt her textbooks by heart.

But she was proud, too.

She knew more than the others and liked to make sure they knew it. When she corrected them, she rarely stopped to consider how she sounded.

‘Do you see what I mean?’ Black asked softly.

Hermione stared down at her book.

The sort of person she disliked most…

Was that how she appeared to everyone else?

No wonder she hadn’t made any friends.

She couldn’t stand those qualities herself. Why should anyone else put up with them?

‘You and Cassandra are quite alike,’ Black continued. ‘You’re both bright, both proud, both determined to be the best. Neither of you has many friends.’

Hermione said nothing.

‘You ought to have plenty to talk about. You grew up in a Muggle family and she grew up in a wizarding one, but in some ways, you’ve had much the same experience. Always the cleverest person your age. Never much competition. Eventually, you stopped paying attention to anyone who couldn’t keep up.’

He lowered his voice.

‘But people have more to them than that. If you both gave them a chance, you might find things to like about the people you’ve dismissed.’

She kept her eyes on the page.

‘You’re looking for friends, Hermione. They don’t have to be worthy opponents. Why should it matter whether they’re as good at everything as you are?’

Black shrugged.

‘Surely liking one another is enough.’

By the time he had finished, Hermione’s anger had drained away.

Guilt had taken its place.

Some of the girls in her dormitory had tried talking to her after the feast last night.

Now she remembered what she had said in reply.

Her face burned.

Had she really been that unpleasant?

No wonder everyone had kept their distance today. No wonder nobody had wanted the empty seats beside her.

Then she thought about her one friend.

The boy who was still sitting next to her.

Black knew what she was like, yet he had come over anyway. He was still willing to be her friend.

And she had snapped at him.

‘Black… I’m sorry.’

Her voice was barely above a whisper.

‘Thank you for still being my friend. And for telling me.’

She swallowed.

‘I’ll try to do better.’

[Intense guilt detected.]

[Gold Chest obtained ×1.]

Black was delighted.

He had wanted a chest, of course, but he had also meant to help.

His presence had already caused a few interesting changes. Hermione hadn’t become particularly close to Harry and Ron, which meant the events that would eventually soften her attitude might never happen.

If he did nothing, she could remain isolated.

Naturally, there was also the small matter of explaining Cassandra’s perfume.

Still, judging by Hermione’s expression, she probably wouldn’t be asking about that again.

‘But…’

Black paused.

‘What does any of that have to do with you spending so long with Cassandra that you nearly missed the lesson?’

He turned and found Hermione watching him with bright, attentive eyes.

She still remembered?

After all that?

Fortunately, Black was getting rather good at turning conversations around.

He gave her a mildly surprised look.

‘Have you forgotten what I just said? Like you, she only has one friend. Me.’

Hermione hesitated.

‘Who else is she supposed to spend time with? She can hardly go and find her other friends if she hasn’t got any.’

He gestured towards her.

‘Think about it. Apart from me, who have you got? You only have a slight habit of lecturing people, and they’ve already started avoiding you.’

Hermione winced.

‘Now consider Cassandra’s mouth. You’ve heard her. “Unpopular” hardly covers it.’

Hermione thought about that.

She had certainly experienced Cassandra’s sharp tongue.

And, admittedly, Cassandra was considerably worse.

Her mouth turned down.

‘You were alone together. I thought…’

Black stared at her in apparent horror.

‘What were you thinking? Can’t a boy and a girl simply be friends?’

Then his eyes widened.

‘Wait. Is that what this is? Are you girls only interested in me for my looks?’

He drew back.

‘I’m only a child! Have you no shame?’

Hermione’s self-restraint finally failed.

The Charms textbook flew straight at his face.

‘Ahem!’

Professor Flitwick tapped his desk.

‘That is quite enough.’

It was only their first lesson. He had been telling them stories, and their quiet conversation hadn’t seemed worth interrupting.

Throwing books at one another was another matter.

‘Sorry, Professor,’ Hermione said earnestly. ‘There was a bug on his face. I was trying to squash it.’

Flitwick looked at the book.

‘With your textbook?’

He paused.

Then he shook his head and returned to the lesson.

Later that afternoon came Herbology, the subject Black had been looking forward to most.

Since they were first-years attending their very first lesson, Professor Sprout didn’t set them any practical work. Instead, she led them through the greenhouse, introducing a variety of remarkable fungi and peculiar magical plants.

They would need to learn how to grow them and what each could be used for.

‘Now, who can tell me what this is?’ she asked, indicating a small plant with rounded leaves. ‘And what it does?’

Hermione’s hand shot up.

Before Sprout could call on her, Black raised his own.

He also began speaking.

‘Dittany, Professor. It has powerful healing properties.’

Sprout was a little displeased that he hadn’t waited to be asked.

Only a little.

He was one of her own students, after all. The gifted boy who had kept the Sorting Hat deliberating for more than ten minutes.

The same boy whose loss McGonagall had spent much of last night lamenting to her.

Eager. Knowledgeable. Keen to contribute.

‘Correct! Five points to Hufflepuff.’

Sprout beamed.

Hermione glared at Black.

That was cheating.

You were supposed to raise your hand and wait, not answer while your arm was still going up.

Black ignored her indignation and accepted the Silver Chest she provided.

[Silver Chest obtained ×1.]

Hermione learnt quickly.

At the next question, she raised her hand and answered at once.

She had memorised the textbook. These questions weren’t going to trouble her.

Her answers were correct, precise and thoroughly reliable.

Black, however, kept finding something to add.

By the end of the lesson, Professor Sprout was delighted.

She had rarely enjoyed awarding points quite so much. Better still, every point she had given her own House had been entirely deserved.

Black’s understanding of Herbology had genuinely surprised her.

Her pleasure earned him another reward.

[Gold Chest obtained ×1.]

When they left the greenhouse, Hermione was still annoyed by his methods.

‘You can hardly blame me,’ Black said, spreading his hands. ‘I’m a Hufflepuff. I can’t just hand all the points to Gryffindor.’

By dinner, the four long tables in the Great Hall were laden with food.

After a full day of lessons, the pupils needed little encouragement to eat.

Black was making excellent progress when Wayne Hopkins leaned towards him and asked a baffling question.

‘Have you got something against that Gryffindor girl?’

Black looked up.

‘What makes you think I’ve got something against her?’

They were friends.

Roger Malone leaned in from the other side.

‘Come on, mate. You’ve been at her all afternoon.’

‘What?’

‘In Charms. You kept talking at her. I couldn’t hear what you were saying, but she looked furious.’

Wayne nodded.

‘She looked as though she wanted to hit you with that book for ages. We were getting worried.’

‘And then we all saw what happened,’ Roger added.

‘She finally snapped and threw it at your face,’ Wayne said. ‘You’re saying there’s nothing going on?’

‘And Herbology,’ Roger continued. ‘Every time she answered a question, up went your hand. Always something to pick at.’

He regarded Black seriously.

‘If that isn’t a feud, what is?’

Black had no immediate answer.

To be fair, Hermione had been the only one answering questions towards the end of Herbology.

With him adding something after each answer, it probably had looked as though he was singling her out.

If only one other Gryffindor had put their hand up…

He sighed.

He had wanted to make a good impression on Professor Sprout and earn a chest.

That was all.

He hadn’t been trying to start an argument.

Was this really what his friendship with Hermione looked like from the outside?

‘We haven’t got anything against each other.’

It took a considerable amount of explanation before his roommates finally seemed willing to believe him.

Mostly.

Black had just breathed a sigh of relief and turned back to his dinner when another handsome face appeared.

Cedric sat down beside him.

‘I hear you’ve got a feud going with a Gryffindor girl?’

Black stared.

‘You too? Is there any gossip in this school you don’t listen to?’

🌟 The story is already written… waiting to be unleashed.

🔥 Your power determines how fast the tale unfolds.

If you liked the chapter

If you find any errors (non-standard content, ads redirect, broken links, etc..), Please let us know so we can fix it as soon as possible.

Report

Use arrow keys (or A / D) to PREV/NEXT chapter