Chapter 133: Weighing Options

The smoke and blood of Golden Ear Valley reached Casterly Rock as ink.

Smith’s report lay upon Arthur Greyoak’s desk, written in the spare, exact hand of a soldier who had no taste for decoration when numbers would do. It named the dead, counted the wounded, listed captured horses, wagons, mail, bows, spears, prisoners, and banners, and ended with a careful assessment of Highgarden’s likely answer. The Bannermen Guard had won a great victory. Men would sing of it badly within the moon. Lords would praise it in letters while calculating what it cost them. Smallfolk would hear that western steel had broken Reach pride and perhaps sleep a little easier, until the next tax collector came.

It was the sort of victory that could make any lord call for three days of feasting.

Arthur did not.

He sat behind a great desk carved from a single slab of dark oak, his back to a tapestry newly worked with the Westerlands, the Riverlands, the northern roads, and the edge of the Reach. Candles burned low around him, their light unsteady upon his face. He had read Smith’s report twice. Then he had turned to the other papers, because victory, if it is to be useful, must survive its own congratulations.

Alwin’s report was first, and it was as cheerful as a grave in winter. The deficit remained severe. Trade had begun to recover through Lannisport, Seagard, and the rivers, but reconstruction swallowed coin faster than mines could cough it up. Granaries, roads, canals, workshops, pensions, tools, wages, shipyards, garrisons, and the feeding of the new army all demanded silver, timber, grain, and time. The treasury could sustain three moons of ordinary expenses and border defense. If a larger war began, taxes would need to rise, or loans be taken, and either course risked unrest.

Arthur set that aside without smiling. War always had a bill. Reconstruction had several, and all of them arrived before supper.

The Riverlands report was no kinder. Jason Mallister and the great lords who had bent the knee remained firm, for now. But many lesser and middling lords, especially near the Vale and among those with old ties to House Tully, were still uncertain. They obeyed in public, delayed in private, and watched the winds with the careful loyalty of men deciding whether a storm would pass. New laws, new levies, new taxes, and the cost of war pressed upon the Trident. Victory at Golden Ear Valley had impressed them, but fear and admiration were poor mortar if hunger got between the stones. The report ended with a quieter line: certain discontented river lords had opened secret correspondence with Petyr Baelish in the Vale.

Littlefinger. Naturally. Put a crack in a wall and some men will poke knives through it before asking who owns the house.

The reports from the north were greyer still. Winterfell stood, but its strength had been hollowed. Bran Stark held nominal authority with Maester Luwin’s aid, yet command over the North remained thin and frayed. Umbers, Mormonts, and other houses had bled badly at the Wall. House Karstark remained outwardly loyal, though their temper was difficult to read. The Free Folk settlements, the future of the Night’s Watch, the damage of winter and war, and the endless need for food made the North a burden rather than an ally. Jon Snow remained unconscious. Arya Stark was stable, but far from healed.

Arthur paused on those names longer than the rest.

Then came the letter from Dorne.

It was careful, polished, and sharp enough to shave with. Prince Doran Martell congratulated the Westerlands and Riverlands on their “brilliant victory” at the border, which was the kind of courtesy that usually meant a dagger had not yet been drawn. He observed that the roses of Highgarden were bruised, not uprooted, and that the Reach had deep roots, many allies, and friends in King’s Landing and among the remnants of the Stormlands. He then expressed Dorne’s concern for “the peace and balance of the Seven Kingdoms” and suggested that if the war lengthened or spread too far, Dorne might be compelled to take measures to protect its interests and the balance of the south.

The meaning was naked under its silks. Do not try to swallow Highgarden. Dorne will not watch forever.

Arthur tapped one finger against the desk.

If you come across this story on Amazon, it's taken without permission from the author. Report it.

Golden Ear Valley had changed the battlefield, not the war. That was the trouble with victories. They made men believe a door had opened, when often they had only found a better-decorated wall.

The Riverlands were not settled deeply enough to bear a long war. The North could not help him and might soon need him. Highgarden was wounded, not broken. Dorne had shown its teeth without opening its mouth. Cersei remained mad, dangerous, and too close to a throne for the realm’s health. Daenerys held Dragonstone with wounded dragons and wounded pride. The sea was troubled by Redwyne sails, Ironborn madness, and Dornish patience. His own lands needed time more than triumph.

Now was not the hour to destroy Highgarden.

Arthur looked at the map. His fingers traced Pheasant Hall, then Golden Ear Valley, then the border near Old Oak. From there he moved south to Highgarden, farther south to Dorne, then eastward across the Narrow Sea’s edge to Dragonstone. The shape of the answer formed slowly, unpleasantly, and therefore probably honestly.

The victory would be used for bargaining, not conquest.

He took up his quill.

To Smith and Diana at Pheasant Hall, he wrote first. Golden Ear Valley was to be honored as a great achievement, but there would be no reckless pursuit. They were to stabilize Pheasant Hall, repair the walls, replenish stores, and halt any large-scale cross-border offensive. Small elite parties could continue controlled harassment along Highgarden’s border, but nothing that would hand the Reach a clean claim of invasion. Defenses were to be strengthened. Troops were to continue training. Supplies were to be gathered. Scouts were to watch Old Oak, Highgarden’s border strongholds, and any movement in the eastern Riverlands and toward the Vale.

That should disappoint the men who thought winning one battle made them immortal. Good. Disappointment keeps fools alive when wisdom is unavailable.

To Jason Mallister at Seagard, he wrote next. The victory at sea had restored morale and kept the western waterways breathing, but the fleet was not to seek another grand battle unless forced. Mallister was to maintain control of Ironman’s Bay and the sea road from Seagard down to Lannisport, press cautiously toward the Redwyne waters to deter the Arbor, protect coastal trade between the Westerlands and Riverlands, hunt pirates, especially Ironborn remnants, and strengthen watch upon Dornish coastal movements.

The sea, like a court, rewarded men who knew when to smile and when to knife someone in the ribs. Jason Mallister knew both well enough.

To Alwin, Arthur sent the least glamorous and most necessary commands. Reconstruction and trade were to quicken. Land reclamation, mining, workshops, shipbuilding, and river transport were to receive priority. Newly sworn river lords were to be offered tax relief and trade privileges in exchange for cooperation, punctual levies, and enforcement of the new decrees. Families of the fallen were to be compensated. Men who served well were to be rewarded publicly, and wounded soldiers given land, stipends, or work before resentment found them. The people must see that the new order paid its debts. Men forgive many things in a lord who pays.

Then came the letters that required fewer hands to know of them.

Through the Grey Shadows, a message would go to Dragonstone, for Daenerys Targaryen, or failing that, Tyrion Lannister and Varys. The war in the southwest had bloodied Highgarden and tied down a large part of its strength. The alliance between King’s Landing and Highgarden was strained, and this was a moment to move. The Westerlands and Riverlands would remain formally limited in their involvement, but could provide timber, metals, and certain supplies if Daenerys pressed King’s Landing. If she could draw Cersei’s eyes east, stir support in the Stormlands, or open contact with the Vale, the pressure upon the southwest would lessen. Dorne’s attitude was uncertain and should be watched closely. Arthur wished to maintain communication in the interest of stability within the Seven Kingdoms.

He almost laughed at that last phrase. Stability. A pretty word for keeping other people’s fires far enough away to finish building one’s own walls.

The last secret message was for Dorne, to Prince Doran Martell or Prince Oberyn, whichever hand the raven found sharper. Golden Ear Valley, Arthur wrote, had been a response to Highgarden’s aggression. The Westerlands and Riverlands had no intention, nor present ability, to devour the Reach. Their desire was border peace and trade. He recognized Dorne’s interest in independence and balance. A too-powerful Highgarden served neither the southwest nor the south. If Dorne remained neutral or friendly, Arthur was willing, after the war, to discuss disputed border castles, trade routes, and arrangements that would respect Dornish interests. The south did not need mutual ruin. It needed borders, profit, and breathing room.

A lie? Not entirely. A promise? Not quite. Politics lived in such damp spaces. Worms did too, but no system is perfect.

When the last seal was pressed, Arthur sat back and let out a slow breath.

He had chosen the conservative path. It did not feel safe. Safe paths were for children, graves, and men who had never seen a map. This was something else: a dance along the edge of victory, where one wrong step could turn triumph into a pit.

Beyond the windows, Casterly Rock slept uneasily. In the yards, soldiers drilled by torchlight. In Lannisport, shipwrights worked late. In the Riverlands, lords counted costs and loyalty. At Pheasant Hall, men repaired walls that might be tested again within days.

Arthur looked once more at the map.

The board had grown too large for any one hand.

That did not excuse him from moving.